Please note:
this blog has been moved and is continued at: footballminded.wordpress.com
Free Agent Breakdown - Defensive Ends/OLB's
10 years ago
Monday, November 16, 2009
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
2009 Draft Surprises
As usual, things didn't go according to the experts' plans on Draft Weekend, but there were several things that surprised me. It started from the first pick, and followed through to the end of the second day. Some were based on preconceived draft notions, others were shockers as they happened.
1. Matthew Stafford going #1 overall
-While this wasn't a surprise to most, I am still not on the Stafford bandwagon. Scouts love his "live arm" and plethora of starts at the collegiate level, but I still don't see how that alone translates to NFL success. When Stafford was off his game at Georgia, the team's offense was anemic, even with first-round pick Knowshon Moreno in the backfield. In fact, during his three years at Georgia, Stafford played with current and future NFL talents at wide receiver, running back, tight end and offensive line, but still couldn't take his team to an SEC East title. Forget a national or conference championship, is a division title too much to ask for?
While the move to draft Stafford is a view for the future, it could also be a political tactic. By drafting a quarterback, that gives the Lions organization at least three years of more excuses, because you can always say, "Stafford hasn't developed yet." If they drafted a lineman, fans could still demand more wins next year. Now they can only say their number one overall pick needs more time.
2. The Chiefs taking Tyson Jackson at #3
-While Kansas City is switching to a 3-4 defense, I still see this as a reach. Jackson will play the five-technique, which is the defensive end on the line, part defensive tackle, part pass rusher. Jackson might be a good fit for the position at 300 lbs., but I would also make the argument that it is the least important position in the defensive scheme. A 3-4 needs a huge, space-eating defensive tackle in the middle, and fast, outside linebackers to get to the quarterback. Five-technique defensive ends essentially need to be 300+ lbs., and able to occupy offensive tackles or guards so the linebackers can get around the edge. The Chiefs need personnel at both defensive tackle and outside linebacker, and were in a position to take Aaron Curry or B.J. Raji, but passed. I was surprised the Chiefs didn't take either of those players, with a view to take a five-technique end later, which can typically be found in the second day of the draft.
3. The Jets trading up to #5 for Mark Sanchez
-I am again going against the grain of the experts by not being a huge fan of Sanchez. While he was a good quarterback at USC for one season, I still don't see how that warrants a top-five selection. I think far too much credit is given to USC's "pro-style" offense. Sure he takes snaps from under center instead of in the shotgun, but that still doesn't mean the offense was good last year.
When Sanchez first declared for the draft, he was blasted by both his coach, Pete Carroll, and draft pundits who said he needed to go back for his senior year because quarterbacks who leave school early are not ready to start in the NFL. He was pegged as the clear second-ranked quarterback in the class, with no chance to beat out Stafford for top billing. He was projected to be a top-25 pick, at best, and would likely need to sit a year before seeing regular season action.
Being a junior, he was not eligible for post-season all-star games or organized activities, and needed to rely solely on the combine and his Pro Day workout at USC. By not playing in a single game between January and April, Sanchez moved himself from a late first-round pick, to a top-five selection. How?
Sanchez was a redshirt junior, who sat behind Matt Leinart, who had a much better resume for scouts to examine. Leinart won two national championships, a Heisman trophy, and stayed for his senior year.
After Leinart, Sanchez still couldn't beat out John David Booty, a one-and-done starter for the Trojans, who was a fifth-round pick in last year's draft, and has not seen NFL action since.
I still fail to see how a one-year college starter, who could not beat out a future NFL also-ran, declares for the draft, doesn't play for three months, but then skyrockets up draft boards, to the point where a team will trade first- and second-round draft picks, as well as three other players, to go get him at pick number five.
Sanchez talks a great game, and marketed himself very well, I just don't see the same thing everyone else does. I think he will be good, not great, and will need more than a year to develop, especially if he starts right away. As for USC's "pro-style" offense that prepares quarterbacks for the NFL so well? Leinart is a backup for the Cardinals and Booty is fourth on the depth chart after the Vikings traded for Sage Rosenfels in the offseason.
4. Oakland passing on Michael Crabtree for Darrius Heyward-Bey at #7
-Crabtree was widely considered the top receiver in this draft, and although he had a stress fracture in his foot, he was expected to be the first pass catcher off the board. While it is known that Raiders owner Al Davis loves speed and combine measurables, many thought he would take an offensive tackle or a wide receiver, either Crabtree or Jeremy Maclin. Heyward-Bey was considered the fourth- or fifth-best receiver in this draft, projecting him as a late first-round pick. Instead, Davis fell in love with Heyward-Bey's 4.30 40-yard dash time, the fastest of anyone at this year's combine. Crabtree landed nearby, falling to San Francisco at #10. Ay bay bay.
5. Brian Orakpo falling to the Redskins at #13
-After his impressive workouts, Orakpo was thought by many, myself included, to be a sure-fire top-10 pick. While the Mark Sanchez trade re-shuffled the deck, I still expected Orakpo to be the first pass rusher off the board. However, with Tyson Jackson gone with the third pick and Buffalo selecting Aaron Maybin at #11, the possibility loomed that Orakpo would be around at #13. With the Broncos needing 3-4 personnel, I thought Orakpo could be gone at #12, but Denver went with Knowshon Moreno instead. With Orakpo still shockingly on the board, Washington wasted no time, using about 45 seconds of their alotted 10 minutes to make its selection.
6. Rey Maualuga falling to the 2nd round
-I made a prediction before the draft that there was no chance Brian Cushing would be taken ahead of Rey Maualuga. It turns out Maualuga was the last picked of the three USC linebackers expected to be taken in the first round, with Maualuga slipping out of the first round altogether. Cushing went 15th to the Texans, while Clay Matthews went 26th to the Packers. Maualuga went to the Bengals in the second round, 38th overall.
There was speculation, but no confirmation, that Maualuga has a torn hamstring, which could have hurt his draft stock. Regardless, Maualuga was projected to be a top-15 pick, and to see him available in the second round baffled me.
1. Matthew Stafford going #1 overall
-While this wasn't a surprise to most, I am still not on the Stafford bandwagon. Scouts love his "live arm" and plethora of starts at the collegiate level, but I still don't see how that alone translates to NFL success. When Stafford was off his game at Georgia, the team's offense was anemic, even with first-round pick Knowshon Moreno in the backfield. In fact, during his three years at Georgia, Stafford played with current and future NFL talents at wide receiver, running back, tight end and offensive line, but still couldn't take his team to an SEC East title. Forget a national or conference championship, is a division title too much to ask for?
While the move to draft Stafford is a view for the future, it could also be a political tactic. By drafting a quarterback, that gives the Lions organization at least three years of more excuses, because you can always say, "Stafford hasn't developed yet." If they drafted a lineman, fans could still demand more wins next year. Now they can only say their number one overall pick needs more time.
2. The Chiefs taking Tyson Jackson at #3
-While Kansas City is switching to a 3-4 defense, I still see this as a reach. Jackson will play the five-technique, which is the defensive end on the line, part defensive tackle, part pass rusher. Jackson might be a good fit for the position at 300 lbs., but I would also make the argument that it is the least important position in the defensive scheme. A 3-4 needs a huge, space-eating defensive tackle in the middle, and fast, outside linebackers to get to the quarterback. Five-technique defensive ends essentially need to be 300+ lbs., and able to occupy offensive tackles or guards so the linebackers can get around the edge. The Chiefs need personnel at both defensive tackle and outside linebacker, and were in a position to take Aaron Curry or B.J. Raji, but passed. I was surprised the Chiefs didn't take either of those players, with a view to take a five-technique end later, which can typically be found in the second day of the draft.
3. The Jets trading up to #5 for Mark Sanchez
-I am again going against the grain of the experts by not being a huge fan of Sanchez. While he was a good quarterback at USC for one season, I still don't see how that warrants a top-five selection. I think far too much credit is given to USC's "pro-style" offense. Sure he takes snaps from under center instead of in the shotgun, but that still doesn't mean the offense was good last year.
When Sanchez first declared for the draft, he was blasted by both his coach, Pete Carroll, and draft pundits who said he needed to go back for his senior year because quarterbacks who leave school early are not ready to start in the NFL. He was pegged as the clear second-ranked quarterback in the class, with no chance to beat out Stafford for top billing. He was projected to be a top-25 pick, at best, and would likely need to sit a year before seeing regular season action.
Being a junior, he was not eligible for post-season all-star games or organized activities, and needed to rely solely on the combine and his Pro Day workout at USC. By not playing in a single game between January and April, Sanchez moved himself from a late first-round pick, to a top-five selection. How?
Sanchez was a redshirt junior, who sat behind Matt Leinart, who had a much better resume for scouts to examine. Leinart won two national championships, a Heisman trophy, and stayed for his senior year.
After Leinart, Sanchez still couldn't beat out John David Booty, a one-and-done starter for the Trojans, who was a fifth-round pick in last year's draft, and has not seen NFL action since.
I still fail to see how a one-year college starter, who could not beat out a future NFL also-ran, declares for the draft, doesn't play for three months, but then skyrockets up draft boards, to the point where a team will trade first- and second-round draft picks, as well as three other players, to go get him at pick number five.
Sanchez talks a great game, and marketed himself very well, I just don't see the same thing everyone else does. I think he will be good, not great, and will need more than a year to develop, especially if he starts right away. As for USC's "pro-style" offense that prepares quarterbacks for the NFL so well? Leinart is a backup for the Cardinals and Booty is fourth on the depth chart after the Vikings traded for Sage Rosenfels in the offseason.
4. Oakland passing on Michael Crabtree for Darrius Heyward-Bey at #7
-Crabtree was widely considered the top receiver in this draft, and although he had a stress fracture in his foot, he was expected to be the first pass catcher off the board. While it is known that Raiders owner Al Davis loves speed and combine measurables, many thought he would take an offensive tackle or a wide receiver, either Crabtree or Jeremy Maclin. Heyward-Bey was considered the fourth- or fifth-best receiver in this draft, projecting him as a late first-round pick. Instead, Davis fell in love with Heyward-Bey's 4.30 40-yard dash time, the fastest of anyone at this year's combine. Crabtree landed nearby, falling to San Francisco at #10. Ay bay bay.
5. Brian Orakpo falling to the Redskins at #13
-After his impressive workouts, Orakpo was thought by many, myself included, to be a sure-fire top-10 pick. While the Mark Sanchez trade re-shuffled the deck, I still expected Orakpo to be the first pass rusher off the board. However, with Tyson Jackson gone with the third pick and Buffalo selecting Aaron Maybin at #11, the possibility loomed that Orakpo would be around at #13. With the Broncos needing 3-4 personnel, I thought Orakpo could be gone at #12, but Denver went with Knowshon Moreno instead. With Orakpo still shockingly on the board, Washington wasted no time, using about 45 seconds of their alotted 10 minutes to make its selection.
6. Rey Maualuga falling to the 2nd round
-I made a prediction before the draft that there was no chance Brian Cushing would be taken ahead of Rey Maualuga. It turns out Maualuga was the last picked of the three USC linebackers expected to be taken in the first round, with Maualuga slipping out of the first round altogether. Cushing went 15th to the Texans, while Clay Matthews went 26th to the Packers. Maualuga went to the Bengals in the second round, 38th overall.
There was speculation, but no confirmation, that Maualuga has a torn hamstring, which could have hurt his draft stock. Regardless, Maualuga was projected to be a top-15 pick, and to see him available in the second round baffled me.
Thursday, April 23, 2009
2009 NFL Mock Draft
1. Detroit Lions-Jason Smith, OT Baylor
-While Matthew Stafford is projected by most the be the top overall pick in this year’s draft, I don’t consider him an elite prospect, and I’m not sure Detroit is convinced either. While Stafford has a strong arm, his decision making is questionable. The Lions re-upped QB Daunte Culpepper and could look for him to get them through another season. The Lions could look at this situation as though they will be in a similar spot next year, so they might wait until a better quarterback crop comes along next season.
Detroit needs help everywhere after officially recording the worst season in NFL history, finishing 0-16. With two first-round picks, Detroit can make some headway in a number of areas, but the lines should be the priority. With Matt Millen out of the way, this franchise needs to put a gameplan together bring respectability back to the Lions. The best way to do that is to find a cornerstone of the line to protect your quarterback. Last year’s first-round pick, Gosder Cherilus, was a step towards building the offensive line, but that’s not enough.
Baylor offensive tackle Jason Smith is a prospect with a lot of upside, who could start immediately at left tackle. A former tight end, Smith has excellent footwork and continues to improve as an all-around player. His downside is he’s raw, coming from a spread system in college. He never lined up in a three-point stance, so his technique needs work, but his work ethic is relentless and enjoys his work. His quote at the combine of taking pride "in physically assaulting someone" on a football field spoke volumes of his desire for the game and the type of player he wants to become.
2. St. Louis Rams-Eugene Monroe, OT Virginia
-Opinions differ on who the best tackle prospect in this draft, whether it’s Jason Smith or Virginia’s Eugene Monroe. Monroe appears to be a much more polished player at his position. He was good enough to keep Kansas City’s 2008 first-round pick Branden Albert at guard while he was at UVA, and he now starts at left tackle for the Chiefs. Monroe is a better pass protector than Smith, but Smith might have the edge in run blocking. Smith is stronger, but Monroe has great footwork that keeps him from getting beat and is very quick. While Smith has more room for growth, Monroe is a better fit to start right away, but has less potential. Therefore, it’s a choice between taking a solid prospect versus taking a chance on a player who could be an All-Pro, but might fall flat.
With Jason Smith off the board, it makes the selection easier for St. Louis. As much as the Rams throw the ball, they might be better suited to take Monroe anyway. The Rams have serious problems at offensive tackle, as right tackle and former first-round pick Alex Barron has been less than stellar to say the least, and former All-Pro tackle and long-tenured Orlando Pace was cut. The Rams need a tackle in the worst way, probably worse than they need a wide receiver. The Rams cut long-time deep threat Tory Holt, but the emergence of Donnie Avery and the versatility of running back Steven Jackson, can ease that concern. St. Louis needs quarterback protection, and are in prime position to pull the trigger here.
3. Kansas City-Aaron Curry, LB Wake Forest
-With new management coming to Kansas City to turn the franchise around, there are many different directions they could go with this pick. The Chiefs are a young squad and have good pieces, but need to develop. After trading for QB Matt Cassel and LB Mike Vrabel from the Patriots, there are a couple of areas covered with quarterback, running back Larry Johnson, offensive tackle Branden Albert, wide receiver Dwayne Bowe, linebackers Derrick Johnson and Vrabel and cornerback Brandon Flowers. The Chiefs could look defensive line or linebacker here, as the addition of defensive coordinator Clancy Pendergast could see Kansas City switch to a 3-4. Last year’s first-round pick Glenn Dorsey might not be a fit there, and edge rushers would be needed as well.
Wake Forest LB Aaron Curry has been deemed "the safest pick in this draft" and could play any linebacker position in any system. While I’m not an advocate of saying any pick is bust-proof, Curry would make sense here and he could start right away if he’s everything he’s cracked up to be. His versatility could be very useful if Kansas City moves between schemes and if he’s the top-rated player on their board, he’s an easy pick at number three.
4. Seattle Seahawks-Matthew Stafford, QB Georgia
-Most mocks have Stafford going first overall to Detroit, but there’s still no guarantee he’ll be their selection. Stafford has a strong arm and has been compared to Jay Cutler, but his decision making has been knocked and there is a concern that he isn’t ready to be the starter on day one because he left school a year early. However, his talent level is there, and perhaps a year of observing from the sideline would do him just right.
Seattle will be looking towards the future as they move on from the Mike Holmgren era and begin the Jim Mora Jr. regime. That could start with a new franchise quarterback. Matt Hasselbeck will be 34 when the season starts and could be ending his career in the next couple years. Stafford could be the guy to step in immediately after Hasselbeck is gone. If Stafford falls out of the top spot, he won’t slip very far. The Seahawks would get great value with this pick, even though it doesn’t plug an immediate hole. This would be a pick for the future, not the present.
5. Cleveland Browns-Brian Orakpo, DE Texas
-I’ve seen plenty of mock drafts with B.J. Raji landing at this spot. Why? The Browns just traded third-and fifth-round picks for Shaun Rogers last year to be the anchor of their 3-4 scheme at nose tackle. Raji is the exact same kind of player. The Browns need pressure off the edge as well as secondary support in coverage. A seemingly perfect fit for pressure on the quarterback is Brian Orakpo, the workout warrior from Texas. Orakpo projects to be either a DE in a 4-3 or a rush end in a 3-4. He could start immediately for the Browns. However, don’t forget new head coach Eric Mangini selected last year’s combine phenom Vernon Gholston with the Jets in the first round, which has turned out to be a bust so far. Mangini might be timid to do the same, but Orakpo doesn’t disappear in games the way Gholston did at Ohio State.
6. Cincinnati Bengals-B.J. Raji, DT Boston College
-The Bengals have plenty of needs, ranging from offensive and defensive line, to wide receiver. The Bengals are apparently shopping Chad Ochocinco, after turning down the Washington Redskins draft day offer of two first-round picks for him last year. Wide receiver is an issue with the departure of T.J. Houshmandzadeh, but the signing of Laveraneus Coles and selection of wide outs in previous drafts makes it a secondary need.
Offensive line, specifically tackle, should be addressed early, but with two tackles already gone, it’s not good value to take the third-rated tackle with the sixth pick.
Boston College DT B.J. Raji is a good fit here. He’s the top defensive tackle in this year’s draft, and worked with head coach Marvin Lewis at the senior bowl, where Raji absolutely dominated. Keep in mind the Bengals were in the mix for USC DT Sedrick Ellis last year, before New Orleans traded up to get him. Cincinnati still needs help there, so Raji will be difficult to pass up.
7. Oakland Raiders-Jeremy Maclin, WR Missouri
-The Raiders need to look at several areas of concern before making this pick, but owner Al Davis, doesn’t usually like to operate that way. Oakland needs an offensive and defensive tackle, wide receiver and possibly a safety. There’s no safety worth taking here, and with B.J. Raji off the board, defensive tackle is out of the question as well. That would narrow the choices to wide receiver or offensive tackle Andre Smith.
Davis likes flashy picks, particularly prospects with speed. Smith doesn’t really fit that mold, so wide receiver becomes the trendy prediction here. Those familiar with Davis’ rationale say he’s obsessed with the 40-yard dash time, which hurts Michael Crabtree’s chances, since he didn’t run the 40 at the combine or his pro day. Even though he is the top receiver in this draft, that might drop him in favor of Missouri’s Jeremy Maclin, who can return kicks, in addition to lining up out wide and in the slot as a receiver.
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-Michael Crabtree, WR Texas Tech
-The Jaguars have a major need here, and it has been delivered with a bow on top. Crabtree is on top of many teams draft boards and the fact he’s available at #8 is reason enough to take him. The Jags need an offensive tackle, but taking the third rated tackle at #8 is mediocre value compared to landing a top flight receiver. They still haven’t gotten a replacement for Marcus Stroud, who they traded to the Bills last year, so defensive tackle is a concern, but with B.J. Raji off the board, there is no one else in the discussion this early.
WR Reggie Williams didn’t workout as they hoped when they selected him in the first round in 2005, Matt Jones didn’t workout as a first-round pick either, and has been cut following a cocaine charge. High-priced free agent Jerry Porter was injured and has since been cut, so receiver is again a serious need for this team. If Crabtree is still on the board here, there is no way they can pass.
9. Green Bay Packers-Everette Brown, DE Florida St.
-With the Packers switching to a 3-4 defense, personnel need to be brought in right away. Aaron Kampman is being asked to move to edge rusher in this scheme, so Green Bay should be looking at acquiring someone who is a natural fit at that position. Everette Brown is regarded as possibly the best 3-4 rusher in this draft and can get pressure on the quarterback. The Packers might take a look at offensive line by replacing departed tackle Mark Tauscher, but not having defensive players to fit the new scheme would derail the season in a hurry.
10. San Francisco 49ers-Andre Smith, OT Alabama
-Many mocks have the 49ers taking USC QB Mark Sanchez here because of the woes this franchise has suffered since bombing on Alex Smith in 2005. However, the philosophy of head coach Mike Singletary needs to be taken into account here for this pick. Singletary is a defensive-minded, tough coach. He wants to turn this team into a run-first, grind-it-out team. Therefore, QB becomes less of a concern at this point. Right now, the focus of this team is toughening up both lines to pound the competition and control the clock. Immediately, that turns the attention to Alabama tackle Andre Smith. Although his workouts haven’t gone as planned and his screw ups in interviews and at the combine have hurt his stock, Singletary could see the opportunity to mold an individual. Don’t forget how he ripped tight end Vernon Davis last year, but continued to work with him throughout the season. Singletary could do the same thing here. Smith’s game tape is undeniable, and with the right motivator, he could be dominant.
11. Buffalo Bills-Robert Ayers, DE Tennessee
-Ayers is moving up draft boards faster than any other prospect this year, enough so that I’m bumping Penn State’s Aaron Maybin from this pick. Ayers is a good fit in a 4-3 scheme, as he’s big enough to pressure the quarterback with the bull rush and handle the run. Maybin is lighter than Ayers, but both are bulking up so if the Bills decide defensive end is their choice at #11, they’ll have their pick of several high-quality end prospects.
By trading left tackle Jason Peters to Philadelphia, they now have two first-round picks, so the Bills could address DE later in the round, possibly with a player like Larry English. However, the word coming from Buffalo’s camp, is they won’t be looking to replace Peters’ left tackle spot with this pick. Expect them to promote from within and build on the other side of the ball, both on the defensive line and the secondary.
12. Denver Broncos-Mark Sanchez, QB USC
-After trading quarterback Jay Cutler, the Broncos have to be looking to replace him immediately. Kyle Orton will not be taking this team to the Super Bowl anytime soon, so if USC’s Mark Sanchez is still on the board, he should be the selection here. Orton could push Sanchez during his rookie year, until Sanchez is ready to take over full-time.
The entire defense is a huge concern, as Denver moves to a 3-4 and need personnel in each department. However, the Broncos now have two first-round picks after the Cutler deal, so they could begin to address the issue then. Sanchez will not last till pick 18, but a five-technique DE like Tyson Jackson could. Therefore, it would be wise to pull the trigger on a QB now and pick from the plethora of DEs six spots later.
13. Washington Redskins-Michael Oher, OT Ole Miss
-The Redskins have been all over the map during this draft process. They have offered this pick, as well as players and future picks, for Jay Cutler, but were beaten out by the Bears. Owner Dan Snyder is reportedly enthralled with Mark Sanchez, and is considering moving up to get him. There has been talk of offensive tackle, possibly Andre Smith or Ole Miss’ Michael Oher. The USC linebackers have been discussed, specifically Rey Maualuga and Brian Cushing. Defensive end is also a need, and that list is extensive. Right now, Washington’s biggest need is the offensive line. The line as a whole is old, injured, and desperate for an upgrade. Defensive end could be a committee, combining late-round picks with returning veterans Phillip Daniels and Renaldo Wynn. Strongside linebacker needs an upgrade, but that could be found later in the draft or when more cuts are made around the league.
The Redskins need immediate help at right tackle, and will need to replace left tackle Chris Samuels in a few years. The wise choice would be to make an investment now with Michael Oher. He could start right away at right tackle, and then transition to left tackle when Chris Samuels begins to decline. While Oher has been described as a "boom or bust" prospect, he’s no more risky than selecting Rey Maualuga to transfer to strongside linebacker, or taking Brian Cushing, who has a history of injuries. Rumors are circulating that Snyder loves USC QB Mark Sanchez and is prepared to trade up for him. While you'd be moving up to get what you think is a franchise quarterback, it doesn’t matter who it is if there’s no line to protect him. A great quote from Trey Wingo on NFL Live, "No quarterback has ever completed a pass from his back."
14. New Orleans Saints-Malcolm Jenkins, DB Ohio St.
-Some teams don’t know whether to call Malcolm Jenkins a cornerback or a safety. Luckily for the Saints, they need both. Jenkins should get a shot at starting cornerback, but if he fails, he could easily make the transition to safety, as scouts fear he is more of a read-than-react-type of coverage man.
Offense shouldn’t be a main concern for New Orleans, but the release of Deuce McAllister does create a need for a big back to complement the speed of Reggie Bush, who is not an every down runner. Still, as much as Drew Brees throws the ball, defense should be the focus of this team to avoid the need for shootouts every Sunday. Besides, a power back can be found in the second round or early in the second day.
15. Houston Texans-Chris "Beanie" Wells, RB Ohio St.
-Steve Slaton played very well as a rookie last year, but didn’t get help from Ahman Green, whose career appears to be over. The Texans still need a power back to complement Slaton, and could use this pick to snag a physical runner to give them an inside-outside attack. Chris "Beanie" Wells and Knowshon Moreno are regarded as the top backs in this draft, Wells the bigger, tougher runner, and Moreno, the elusive, versatile back. Wells could be what Green never amounted to in Houston and give them some relief, not having to rely so heavily on wide receiver Andre Johnson.
16. San Diego Chargers-Tyson Jackson, DE LSU
-The Chargers are again one of the most talented teams in the league, on paper. Although they haven’t translated that to on-the-field success, they are deep in many positions and can draft luxury items, rather than reach for a player based on need. In this case, the Chargers get a blessing of a great talent, falling to them in an area of need. With the departure of Igor Olshansky in the offseason, the Chargers could use a down end, five-technique lineman in their 3-4 scheme. LSU’s Tyson Jackson fits the bill and more. At nearly 300 pounds, Jackson is a great run stuffer on the end and can move to tackle in passing situations. He is very athletic for his size and can take space against his blockers, allowing edge rushers, like the returning Shawn Merriman, to get to the quarterback.
17. New York Jets-Josh Freeman, QB Kansas St.
-The Brett Favre experiment didn’t work out and was over after one year, leaving the Jets in the same spot as last offseason, in need of a quarterback. Former second-round pick Kellen Clemens hasn’t been handed the job by new head coach Rex Ryan, leaving the door open for competition. If they don’t see him as the future of their franchise, it might be time to look in that direction now.
In the mold of Daunte Culpepper, Josh Freeman is an enormous prospect with an arm to match. At nearly 6’6", 250 lbs., Freeman has the physical tools to succeed in the NFL, but is inexperienced, leaving Kansas State early and not polishing his skills to their ability. However, Freeman shows all the promise of a future star, and brings the big arm they loved from Favre last year. Rex Ryan has spent the offseason building his defense to run the 3-4 the way he wants, so now might be time for him to focus on the offensive side of the ball.
18. Denver Broncos (from Chicago Bears)-Aaron Maybin, DE Penn State
-The Broncos would love for Tyson Jackson to fall this far, but with him being gone, they would like to add a piece to their newly-formed 3-4 defensive scheme. The Broncos need everything, from the entire line, to linebackers. Aaron Maybin is an end with a great first step, who could fit as an end in a 4-3 or a rush linebacker in a 3-4.
The Broncos could look at a number of options here, but will probably stay in the area of down end or rush linebacker with this pick. They just don’t have enough proper personnel on that defense to go into the season with what they have.
19. Tampa Bay Bucs-Rey Maualuga, LB USC
-This scenario works out nicely for the Bucs as they can fill a big need at middle linebacker. After cutting long-tenured, future Hall of Famer Derrick Brooks, Tampa Bay is still looking for his replacement. Rey Maualuga could start immediately at the center of that defense, and his all-out, hard-hitting style of play fits perfectly with the Bucs' brand of football.
Quarterback is also an issue, with the release of Jeff Garcia this offseason, and no named starter yet. They have plenty of quarterbacks on the roster, however, and the recent signing of Byron Leftwich could push a decision on this to a later date, especially with three quarterbacks in a weak class already gone at this point.
20. Detroit Lions (from Dallas Cowboys)-Brian Cushing, LB USC
-The Lions need help in all areas, so this pick could go in any number of directions. However, since they need to plug holes all over the defense, why not select a versatile linebacker who can help you in many of those areas? USC’s Brian Cushing can play all linebacker positions, and has played defensive end, as well as a hybrid-strong safety. Cushing could be moved around to accommodate the Lions needs before settling on a specific position when the team becomes viable again.
21. Philadelphia Eagles-Knowshon Moreno, RB Georgia
-The Eagles would like to replace both of their starting tackles from last year, but traded one of their two first-round picks for former Bills LT Jason Peters, so I don‘t expect them to trade for and draft a tackle with both picks. They need a capable backup for "Mr. Questionable" Brian Westbrook, and Knowshon Moreno fit’s the criteria, with similar elusiveness, as well as the ability to catch the ball out of the backfield.
22. Minnesota Vikings-Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR Maryland
-The Vikings need a QB to be a Super Bowl contender, but they won’t upgrade over Tarvaris Jackson by selecting the fourth-best QB of a weak class in the first round. In addition, they traded for Houston Texans’ backup Sage Rosenfels, who could challenge for the starting spot. Darrius Heyward-Bey blew scouts away by running the fastest 40-yard dash time at the combine. Heyward-Bey can give more options in the passing game as well as be a return specialist.
23. New England Patriots-Clay Matthews, LB USC
-With Tom Brady back, the Patriots should be good to go on offense, with Randy Moss, Wes Welker and the addition of Joey Galloway. A running back could be possible here, but with Beanie Wells and Knowshon Moreno off the board, there isn’t much value. The linebacker corps of their 3-4 scheme needs to be revamped, especially after trading away Mike Vrabel. Clay Matthews is the type of player Bill Belichick loves, a hard-working walk-on with an NFL pedigree who gives everything he has. Matthews might be the best in coverage of the three USC linebackers going in the first round, he could rush off the edge with Vrabel gone and Adalius Thomas gets into his mid-30s.
24. Atlanta Falcons-Larry English, DE Northern Illinois
-The previous selection for the Falcons was tight end Brandon Pettigrew here, but today’s trade for former Chief Tony Gonzalez changes things a bit. Atlanta turned things around in a major way after the Michael Vick debacle, finding a new franchise quarterback in Matt Ryan as a rookie. While their offense was clicking, and should be upgraded with Gonzalez, the defense could use assistance getting to the quarterback. Former first-round pick Jamal Anderson has just two sacks in two seasons, and doesn’t appear to be the player they expected. The Falcons could also use a run-stuffing nose tackle to replace the departed Grady Jackson, but that could be found in later rounds.
Here, Atlanta could be focused on helping defensive end John Abraham. Northern Illinois’ Larry English is a similar player who could still be available. English is a strong defensive end, offsetting his smaller size for the position. His college sack total was impressive, albeit against inferior competition. English has been identified as one of this year’s most underrated prospects by Todd McShay, ESPN’s draft expert who has the sharpest tie in the business, so English could be a great find here.
25. Miami Dolphins-Percy Harvin, WR Florida
-Harvin’s stock has been sliding since it was released that he tested positive for marijuana at the NFL combine. He could fall even further than this if Miami doesn’t take him, but his talent is extremely useful for their offense. Harvin has experience in the spread offense, and was utilized as a quarterback several times, similar to how the Dolphins use the "Wildcat" formation. Harvin can be used as a running back, slot receiver, vertical threat, as well as kick and punt returner. The Dolphins need a receiver, as well as someone who can add wrinkles to their trick plays. Harvin’s versatility could be persuasive enough to bring him to Miami, if they feel his off-the-field issues will not be a problem down the road.
26. Baltimore Ravens-Vontae Davis, CB Illinois
-This is a tough call for the Ravens, who are among the league’s best at drafting. They have been known to draft the best player available, but have also found players to fit their system. They could use a receiver, but have been content to leave the load off Joe Flacco’s shoulders and spread the pressure among their three running backs. The defense has been the hallmark of Baltimore football, so don’t be surprised if you see them go in that direction, especially with the departure of CB Chris McAlister, LB Bart Scott, as well as defensive coordinator Rex Ryan.
Baltimore could look at cornerback, with last year’s starting combo of McAlister and Samari Rolle, not active in those roles anymore. Vonte Davis, brother of 49ers tight end Vernon Davis, has all the measurements of a prototypical NFL cornerback, but hasn’t showed the instincts scouts would like to see. Baltimore could see an opportunity to bring him in and let him learn behind mentors such as Ed Reed and Ray Lewis, giving him time to pick up the nuances of the game.
27. Indianapolis Colts-Peria Jerry, DT Ole Miss
-The Colts have been run over the past few years and need help at defensive tackle. Wide receiver could be a dark horse after Indy cut future Hall of Famer Marvin Harrison, but the Colts may have planned for that when they drafted Anthony Gonzalez a couple years ago. Peria Jerry is the best DT after BJ Raji, and plays with a different style. While Raji is a space stuffer with excellent strength, Jerry gets pressure up the middle with his quickness and technique. Jerry would fill a major need for the Colts.
28. Buffalo Bills (from Carolina through Philadelphia)-Brandon Pettigrew, TE Oklahoma State
-Word has come out of Bills camp that they will not replace left tackle Jason Peters with the picks they received for him. The Bills could use a tight end, and many mocks had them taking Brandon Pettigrew with the 11th pick. Now that they have two first-round picks, they would love to see him fall the to then end of the first round. Pettigrew is regarded as the top tight end in an underwhelming class, mostly because of his all-around game. While South Carolina’s Jared Cook is a more athletic player, who specializes in the passing game, Pettigrew runs crisp routes and is a much better blocker. Therefore, Pettigrew is a solid, three-down player, who can be used in all formations.
With a suspension looming for running back Marshawn Lynch, the Bills could focus heavily on their passing game next year. After signing Terrell Owens, the Bills could also add a tight end to maximize their options for a young Trent Edwards.
29. New York Giants-Hakeem Nicks, WR UNC
-This pick has been entirely dependent on the Plaxico Burress situation. Without Burress, the Giants are a completely different team, and Eli Manning becomes a much more pedestrian quarterback. Their running game and offensive line are solid, although the loss of Derrick Ward could see the G-Men picking a running back in later rounds. With Burress gone, the Giants will need to invest in the wide receiver position yet again, despite taking Sinorice Moss, Steve Smith and Mario Manningham the past three years. After cutting ties with Amani Toomer, that position is a weakness without their #1 and #2 receivers of last season.
The Giants stacked their defensive line by adding former Dallas Cowboy, Chris Canty, and Osi Umenyiora will return from a torn lateral meniscus that kept him from playing all of last year. Defensive line will probably not be touched in this class. Drafting a linebacker could also be an option, as the Giants haven’t successfully replaced Kawika Mitchell following their Super Bowl-winning season in 2007-8.
30. Tennessee Titans-Alex Mack, C Cal
-The Titans have several needs for playmakers on both sides of the ball. Wide receiver has been an issue that has been overlooked for the past few drafts, and the departure of Albert Haynesworth to the Washington Redskins could require upgrades for both the defensive line and the secondary, who thrived off pressure from just a four-man rush. However, the Titans do like Jason Jones as a potential replacement for Haynesworth, and they could pass on cornerbacks until the second day.
Center Kevin Mawae is becoming ancient and could be viewing retirement after this year. University of California-Berkeley center Alex Mack is one of the best to come along in some time, and his versatility could allow him to play guard until Mawae is gone. The Titans are a team that loves to build through the trenches, even if it means leaving talent lacking on the outsides. Receiver could be an option here but with five already off the board here, the value is decreased. Unless the Titans fall in love with Rutgers WR Kenny Britt, don’t be surprised to see them stick with the lines here.
31. Arizona Cardinals-Connor Barwin, LB Cincinnati
-After a dream run to the Super Bowl last year, the Cardinals are back to build on a successful season. The big question for this pick is, "Will Anquan Boldin be on the roster?" Boldin has been demanding a new deal since last year and publicly expressed his displeasure with the organization. If Boldin is gone, the Cardinals have showed they can go on without him, but would likely need to add other pieces, like another running back or receiving tight end. If he is there, the Cards should look at upgrading the defense.
While Arizona did make it to the Super Bowl, it wasn’t enough to save defensive coordinator Clancy Pendergast’s job, so expect an investment in a few areas before the draft is over. With a solid secondary, the defensive line could use improvements, building around DT Darnell Dockett. Defensive end is a concern, and unless last year’s second-round pick, DE Calais Campbell, has a break-out season, the Cardinals will have whiffed on DT Gabe Watson, DT Alan Branch and Campbell in consecutive years. While it would be painful to use another high pick on those positions, they could take a different approach and go for speed over size. Cincinnati’s Connor Barwin could be a sleeper with this pick, as a big, speedy outside linebacker with the ability to play defensive end. He clocked a 4.47 at the combine and could be the disruption needed from the edge in the Cardinals’ scheme.
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Eben Britton, OT Arizona
-Look for Oregon C Max Unger to possibly be this pick as well. The Steelers have glaring concerns on their offensive line, despite winning the Super Bowl last season. Tackle Marvel Smith departed in free agency, and Willie Colon and Max Starks are not long-term solutions, after franchising Starks and tendering Colon. Center and guard could use improvements as well, which makes Unger a possibility because of his ability to play anywhere on the interior of the line.
Eben Britton would be a good pickup here because of his ability to play on both the left and right sides. As the best of the second tier of tackles, Britton projects to be a solid player at the next level, no matter which side you put him on. The Steelers will likely be in the same position at tackle next year if they don’t address it in this draft, so it would be better to have someone in the system before that time comes. Unger would be a nice selection, but will probably be available in the second round if the Steelers would like to move up to get him. If not, there are other skilled centers in this draft and guards can be found much later than the first round.
-While Matthew Stafford is projected by most the be the top overall pick in this year’s draft, I don’t consider him an elite prospect, and I’m not sure Detroit is convinced either. While Stafford has a strong arm, his decision making is questionable. The Lions re-upped QB Daunte Culpepper and could look for him to get them through another season. The Lions could look at this situation as though they will be in a similar spot next year, so they might wait until a better quarterback crop comes along next season.
Detroit needs help everywhere after officially recording the worst season in NFL history, finishing 0-16. With two first-round picks, Detroit can make some headway in a number of areas, but the lines should be the priority. With Matt Millen out of the way, this franchise needs to put a gameplan together bring respectability back to the Lions. The best way to do that is to find a cornerstone of the line to protect your quarterback. Last year’s first-round pick, Gosder Cherilus, was a step towards building the offensive line, but that’s not enough.
Baylor offensive tackle Jason Smith is a prospect with a lot of upside, who could start immediately at left tackle. A former tight end, Smith has excellent footwork and continues to improve as an all-around player. His downside is he’s raw, coming from a spread system in college. He never lined up in a three-point stance, so his technique needs work, but his work ethic is relentless and enjoys his work. His quote at the combine of taking pride "in physically assaulting someone" on a football field spoke volumes of his desire for the game and the type of player he wants to become.
2. St. Louis Rams-Eugene Monroe, OT Virginia
-Opinions differ on who the best tackle prospect in this draft, whether it’s Jason Smith or Virginia’s Eugene Monroe. Monroe appears to be a much more polished player at his position. He was good enough to keep Kansas City’s 2008 first-round pick Branden Albert at guard while he was at UVA, and he now starts at left tackle for the Chiefs. Monroe is a better pass protector than Smith, but Smith might have the edge in run blocking. Smith is stronger, but Monroe has great footwork that keeps him from getting beat and is very quick. While Smith has more room for growth, Monroe is a better fit to start right away, but has less potential. Therefore, it’s a choice between taking a solid prospect versus taking a chance on a player who could be an All-Pro, but might fall flat.
With Jason Smith off the board, it makes the selection easier for St. Louis. As much as the Rams throw the ball, they might be better suited to take Monroe anyway. The Rams have serious problems at offensive tackle, as right tackle and former first-round pick Alex Barron has been less than stellar to say the least, and former All-Pro tackle and long-tenured Orlando Pace was cut. The Rams need a tackle in the worst way, probably worse than they need a wide receiver. The Rams cut long-time deep threat Tory Holt, but the emergence of Donnie Avery and the versatility of running back Steven Jackson, can ease that concern. St. Louis needs quarterback protection, and are in prime position to pull the trigger here.
3. Kansas City-Aaron Curry, LB Wake Forest
-With new management coming to Kansas City to turn the franchise around, there are many different directions they could go with this pick. The Chiefs are a young squad and have good pieces, but need to develop. After trading for QB Matt Cassel and LB Mike Vrabel from the Patriots, there are a couple of areas covered with quarterback, running back Larry Johnson, offensive tackle Branden Albert, wide receiver Dwayne Bowe, linebackers Derrick Johnson and Vrabel and cornerback Brandon Flowers. The Chiefs could look defensive line or linebacker here, as the addition of defensive coordinator Clancy Pendergast could see Kansas City switch to a 3-4. Last year’s first-round pick Glenn Dorsey might not be a fit there, and edge rushers would be needed as well.
Wake Forest LB Aaron Curry has been deemed "the safest pick in this draft" and could play any linebacker position in any system. While I’m not an advocate of saying any pick is bust-proof, Curry would make sense here and he could start right away if he’s everything he’s cracked up to be. His versatility could be very useful if Kansas City moves between schemes and if he’s the top-rated player on their board, he’s an easy pick at number three.
4. Seattle Seahawks-Matthew Stafford, QB Georgia
-Most mocks have Stafford going first overall to Detroit, but there’s still no guarantee he’ll be their selection. Stafford has a strong arm and has been compared to Jay Cutler, but his decision making has been knocked and there is a concern that he isn’t ready to be the starter on day one because he left school a year early. However, his talent level is there, and perhaps a year of observing from the sideline would do him just right.
Seattle will be looking towards the future as they move on from the Mike Holmgren era and begin the Jim Mora Jr. regime. That could start with a new franchise quarterback. Matt Hasselbeck will be 34 when the season starts and could be ending his career in the next couple years. Stafford could be the guy to step in immediately after Hasselbeck is gone. If Stafford falls out of the top spot, he won’t slip very far. The Seahawks would get great value with this pick, even though it doesn’t plug an immediate hole. This would be a pick for the future, not the present.
5. Cleveland Browns-Brian Orakpo, DE Texas
-I’ve seen plenty of mock drafts with B.J. Raji landing at this spot. Why? The Browns just traded third-and fifth-round picks for Shaun Rogers last year to be the anchor of their 3-4 scheme at nose tackle. Raji is the exact same kind of player. The Browns need pressure off the edge as well as secondary support in coverage. A seemingly perfect fit for pressure on the quarterback is Brian Orakpo, the workout warrior from Texas. Orakpo projects to be either a DE in a 4-3 or a rush end in a 3-4. He could start immediately for the Browns. However, don’t forget new head coach Eric Mangini selected last year’s combine phenom Vernon Gholston with the Jets in the first round, which has turned out to be a bust so far. Mangini might be timid to do the same, but Orakpo doesn’t disappear in games the way Gholston did at Ohio State.
6. Cincinnati Bengals-B.J. Raji, DT Boston College
-The Bengals have plenty of needs, ranging from offensive and defensive line, to wide receiver. The Bengals are apparently shopping Chad Ochocinco, after turning down the Washington Redskins draft day offer of two first-round picks for him last year. Wide receiver is an issue with the departure of T.J. Houshmandzadeh, but the signing of Laveraneus Coles and selection of wide outs in previous drafts makes it a secondary need.
Offensive line, specifically tackle, should be addressed early, but with two tackles already gone, it’s not good value to take the third-rated tackle with the sixth pick.
Boston College DT B.J. Raji is a good fit here. He’s the top defensive tackle in this year’s draft, and worked with head coach Marvin Lewis at the senior bowl, where Raji absolutely dominated. Keep in mind the Bengals were in the mix for USC DT Sedrick Ellis last year, before New Orleans traded up to get him. Cincinnati still needs help there, so Raji will be difficult to pass up.
7. Oakland Raiders-Jeremy Maclin, WR Missouri
-The Raiders need to look at several areas of concern before making this pick, but owner Al Davis, doesn’t usually like to operate that way. Oakland needs an offensive and defensive tackle, wide receiver and possibly a safety. There’s no safety worth taking here, and with B.J. Raji off the board, defensive tackle is out of the question as well. That would narrow the choices to wide receiver or offensive tackle Andre Smith.
Davis likes flashy picks, particularly prospects with speed. Smith doesn’t really fit that mold, so wide receiver becomes the trendy prediction here. Those familiar with Davis’ rationale say he’s obsessed with the 40-yard dash time, which hurts Michael Crabtree’s chances, since he didn’t run the 40 at the combine or his pro day. Even though he is the top receiver in this draft, that might drop him in favor of Missouri’s Jeremy Maclin, who can return kicks, in addition to lining up out wide and in the slot as a receiver.
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-Michael Crabtree, WR Texas Tech
-The Jaguars have a major need here, and it has been delivered with a bow on top. Crabtree is on top of many teams draft boards and the fact he’s available at #8 is reason enough to take him. The Jags need an offensive tackle, but taking the third rated tackle at #8 is mediocre value compared to landing a top flight receiver. They still haven’t gotten a replacement for Marcus Stroud, who they traded to the Bills last year, so defensive tackle is a concern, but with B.J. Raji off the board, there is no one else in the discussion this early.
WR Reggie Williams didn’t workout as they hoped when they selected him in the first round in 2005, Matt Jones didn’t workout as a first-round pick either, and has been cut following a cocaine charge. High-priced free agent Jerry Porter was injured and has since been cut, so receiver is again a serious need for this team. If Crabtree is still on the board here, there is no way they can pass.
9. Green Bay Packers-Everette Brown, DE Florida St.
-With the Packers switching to a 3-4 defense, personnel need to be brought in right away. Aaron Kampman is being asked to move to edge rusher in this scheme, so Green Bay should be looking at acquiring someone who is a natural fit at that position. Everette Brown is regarded as possibly the best 3-4 rusher in this draft and can get pressure on the quarterback. The Packers might take a look at offensive line by replacing departed tackle Mark Tauscher, but not having defensive players to fit the new scheme would derail the season in a hurry.
10. San Francisco 49ers-Andre Smith, OT Alabama
-Many mocks have the 49ers taking USC QB Mark Sanchez here because of the woes this franchise has suffered since bombing on Alex Smith in 2005. However, the philosophy of head coach Mike Singletary needs to be taken into account here for this pick. Singletary is a defensive-minded, tough coach. He wants to turn this team into a run-first, grind-it-out team. Therefore, QB becomes less of a concern at this point. Right now, the focus of this team is toughening up both lines to pound the competition and control the clock. Immediately, that turns the attention to Alabama tackle Andre Smith. Although his workouts haven’t gone as planned and his screw ups in interviews and at the combine have hurt his stock, Singletary could see the opportunity to mold an individual. Don’t forget how he ripped tight end Vernon Davis last year, but continued to work with him throughout the season. Singletary could do the same thing here. Smith’s game tape is undeniable, and with the right motivator, he could be dominant.
11. Buffalo Bills-Robert Ayers, DE Tennessee
-Ayers is moving up draft boards faster than any other prospect this year, enough so that I’m bumping Penn State’s Aaron Maybin from this pick. Ayers is a good fit in a 4-3 scheme, as he’s big enough to pressure the quarterback with the bull rush and handle the run. Maybin is lighter than Ayers, but both are bulking up so if the Bills decide defensive end is their choice at #11, they’ll have their pick of several high-quality end prospects.
By trading left tackle Jason Peters to Philadelphia, they now have two first-round picks, so the Bills could address DE later in the round, possibly with a player like Larry English. However, the word coming from Buffalo’s camp, is they won’t be looking to replace Peters’ left tackle spot with this pick. Expect them to promote from within and build on the other side of the ball, both on the defensive line and the secondary.
12. Denver Broncos-Mark Sanchez, QB USC
-After trading quarterback Jay Cutler, the Broncos have to be looking to replace him immediately. Kyle Orton will not be taking this team to the Super Bowl anytime soon, so if USC’s Mark Sanchez is still on the board, he should be the selection here. Orton could push Sanchez during his rookie year, until Sanchez is ready to take over full-time.
The entire defense is a huge concern, as Denver moves to a 3-4 and need personnel in each department. However, the Broncos now have two first-round picks after the Cutler deal, so they could begin to address the issue then. Sanchez will not last till pick 18, but a five-technique DE like Tyson Jackson could. Therefore, it would be wise to pull the trigger on a QB now and pick from the plethora of DEs six spots later.
13. Washington Redskins-Michael Oher, OT Ole Miss
-The Redskins have been all over the map during this draft process. They have offered this pick, as well as players and future picks, for Jay Cutler, but were beaten out by the Bears. Owner Dan Snyder is reportedly enthralled with Mark Sanchez, and is considering moving up to get him. There has been talk of offensive tackle, possibly Andre Smith or Ole Miss’ Michael Oher. The USC linebackers have been discussed, specifically Rey Maualuga and Brian Cushing. Defensive end is also a need, and that list is extensive. Right now, Washington’s biggest need is the offensive line. The line as a whole is old, injured, and desperate for an upgrade. Defensive end could be a committee, combining late-round picks with returning veterans Phillip Daniels and Renaldo Wynn. Strongside linebacker needs an upgrade, but that could be found later in the draft or when more cuts are made around the league.
The Redskins need immediate help at right tackle, and will need to replace left tackle Chris Samuels in a few years. The wise choice would be to make an investment now with Michael Oher. He could start right away at right tackle, and then transition to left tackle when Chris Samuels begins to decline. While Oher has been described as a "boom or bust" prospect, he’s no more risky than selecting Rey Maualuga to transfer to strongside linebacker, or taking Brian Cushing, who has a history of injuries. Rumors are circulating that Snyder loves USC QB Mark Sanchez and is prepared to trade up for him. While you'd be moving up to get what you think is a franchise quarterback, it doesn’t matter who it is if there’s no line to protect him. A great quote from Trey Wingo on NFL Live, "No quarterback has ever completed a pass from his back."
14. New Orleans Saints-Malcolm Jenkins, DB Ohio St.
-Some teams don’t know whether to call Malcolm Jenkins a cornerback or a safety. Luckily for the Saints, they need both. Jenkins should get a shot at starting cornerback, but if he fails, he could easily make the transition to safety, as scouts fear he is more of a read-than-react-type of coverage man.
Offense shouldn’t be a main concern for New Orleans, but the release of Deuce McAllister does create a need for a big back to complement the speed of Reggie Bush, who is not an every down runner. Still, as much as Drew Brees throws the ball, defense should be the focus of this team to avoid the need for shootouts every Sunday. Besides, a power back can be found in the second round or early in the second day.
15. Houston Texans-Chris "Beanie" Wells, RB Ohio St.
-Steve Slaton played very well as a rookie last year, but didn’t get help from Ahman Green, whose career appears to be over. The Texans still need a power back to complement Slaton, and could use this pick to snag a physical runner to give them an inside-outside attack. Chris "Beanie" Wells and Knowshon Moreno are regarded as the top backs in this draft, Wells the bigger, tougher runner, and Moreno, the elusive, versatile back. Wells could be what Green never amounted to in Houston and give them some relief, not having to rely so heavily on wide receiver Andre Johnson.
16. San Diego Chargers-Tyson Jackson, DE LSU
-The Chargers are again one of the most talented teams in the league, on paper. Although they haven’t translated that to on-the-field success, they are deep in many positions and can draft luxury items, rather than reach for a player based on need. In this case, the Chargers get a blessing of a great talent, falling to them in an area of need. With the departure of Igor Olshansky in the offseason, the Chargers could use a down end, five-technique lineman in their 3-4 scheme. LSU’s Tyson Jackson fits the bill and more. At nearly 300 pounds, Jackson is a great run stuffer on the end and can move to tackle in passing situations. He is very athletic for his size and can take space against his blockers, allowing edge rushers, like the returning Shawn Merriman, to get to the quarterback.
17. New York Jets-Josh Freeman, QB Kansas St.
-The Brett Favre experiment didn’t work out and was over after one year, leaving the Jets in the same spot as last offseason, in need of a quarterback. Former second-round pick Kellen Clemens hasn’t been handed the job by new head coach Rex Ryan, leaving the door open for competition. If they don’t see him as the future of their franchise, it might be time to look in that direction now.
In the mold of Daunte Culpepper, Josh Freeman is an enormous prospect with an arm to match. At nearly 6’6", 250 lbs., Freeman has the physical tools to succeed in the NFL, but is inexperienced, leaving Kansas State early and not polishing his skills to their ability. However, Freeman shows all the promise of a future star, and brings the big arm they loved from Favre last year. Rex Ryan has spent the offseason building his defense to run the 3-4 the way he wants, so now might be time for him to focus on the offensive side of the ball.
18. Denver Broncos (from Chicago Bears)-Aaron Maybin, DE Penn State
-The Broncos would love for Tyson Jackson to fall this far, but with him being gone, they would like to add a piece to their newly-formed 3-4 defensive scheme. The Broncos need everything, from the entire line, to linebackers. Aaron Maybin is an end with a great first step, who could fit as an end in a 4-3 or a rush linebacker in a 3-4.
The Broncos could look at a number of options here, but will probably stay in the area of down end or rush linebacker with this pick. They just don’t have enough proper personnel on that defense to go into the season with what they have.
19. Tampa Bay Bucs-Rey Maualuga, LB USC
-This scenario works out nicely for the Bucs as they can fill a big need at middle linebacker. After cutting long-tenured, future Hall of Famer Derrick Brooks, Tampa Bay is still looking for his replacement. Rey Maualuga could start immediately at the center of that defense, and his all-out, hard-hitting style of play fits perfectly with the Bucs' brand of football.
Quarterback is also an issue, with the release of Jeff Garcia this offseason, and no named starter yet. They have plenty of quarterbacks on the roster, however, and the recent signing of Byron Leftwich could push a decision on this to a later date, especially with three quarterbacks in a weak class already gone at this point.
20. Detroit Lions (from Dallas Cowboys)-Brian Cushing, LB USC
-The Lions need help in all areas, so this pick could go in any number of directions. However, since they need to plug holes all over the defense, why not select a versatile linebacker who can help you in many of those areas? USC’s Brian Cushing can play all linebacker positions, and has played defensive end, as well as a hybrid-strong safety. Cushing could be moved around to accommodate the Lions needs before settling on a specific position when the team becomes viable again.
21. Philadelphia Eagles-Knowshon Moreno, RB Georgia
-The Eagles would like to replace both of their starting tackles from last year, but traded one of their two first-round picks for former Bills LT Jason Peters, so I don‘t expect them to trade for and draft a tackle with both picks. They need a capable backup for "Mr. Questionable" Brian Westbrook, and Knowshon Moreno fit’s the criteria, with similar elusiveness, as well as the ability to catch the ball out of the backfield.
22. Minnesota Vikings-Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR Maryland
-The Vikings need a QB to be a Super Bowl contender, but they won’t upgrade over Tarvaris Jackson by selecting the fourth-best QB of a weak class in the first round. In addition, they traded for Houston Texans’ backup Sage Rosenfels, who could challenge for the starting spot. Darrius Heyward-Bey blew scouts away by running the fastest 40-yard dash time at the combine. Heyward-Bey can give more options in the passing game as well as be a return specialist.
23. New England Patriots-Clay Matthews, LB USC
-With Tom Brady back, the Patriots should be good to go on offense, with Randy Moss, Wes Welker and the addition of Joey Galloway. A running back could be possible here, but with Beanie Wells and Knowshon Moreno off the board, there isn’t much value. The linebacker corps of their 3-4 scheme needs to be revamped, especially after trading away Mike Vrabel. Clay Matthews is the type of player Bill Belichick loves, a hard-working walk-on with an NFL pedigree who gives everything he has. Matthews might be the best in coverage of the three USC linebackers going in the first round, he could rush off the edge with Vrabel gone and Adalius Thomas gets into his mid-30s.
24. Atlanta Falcons-Larry English, DE Northern Illinois
-The previous selection for the Falcons was tight end Brandon Pettigrew here, but today’s trade for former Chief Tony Gonzalez changes things a bit. Atlanta turned things around in a major way after the Michael Vick debacle, finding a new franchise quarterback in Matt Ryan as a rookie. While their offense was clicking, and should be upgraded with Gonzalez, the defense could use assistance getting to the quarterback. Former first-round pick Jamal Anderson has just two sacks in two seasons, and doesn’t appear to be the player they expected. The Falcons could also use a run-stuffing nose tackle to replace the departed Grady Jackson, but that could be found in later rounds.
Here, Atlanta could be focused on helping defensive end John Abraham. Northern Illinois’ Larry English is a similar player who could still be available. English is a strong defensive end, offsetting his smaller size for the position. His college sack total was impressive, albeit against inferior competition. English has been identified as one of this year’s most underrated prospects by Todd McShay, ESPN’s draft expert who has the sharpest tie in the business, so English could be a great find here.
25. Miami Dolphins-Percy Harvin, WR Florida
-Harvin’s stock has been sliding since it was released that he tested positive for marijuana at the NFL combine. He could fall even further than this if Miami doesn’t take him, but his talent is extremely useful for their offense. Harvin has experience in the spread offense, and was utilized as a quarterback several times, similar to how the Dolphins use the "Wildcat" formation. Harvin can be used as a running back, slot receiver, vertical threat, as well as kick and punt returner. The Dolphins need a receiver, as well as someone who can add wrinkles to their trick plays. Harvin’s versatility could be persuasive enough to bring him to Miami, if they feel his off-the-field issues will not be a problem down the road.
26. Baltimore Ravens-Vontae Davis, CB Illinois
-This is a tough call for the Ravens, who are among the league’s best at drafting. They have been known to draft the best player available, but have also found players to fit their system. They could use a receiver, but have been content to leave the load off Joe Flacco’s shoulders and spread the pressure among their three running backs. The defense has been the hallmark of Baltimore football, so don’t be surprised if you see them go in that direction, especially with the departure of CB Chris McAlister, LB Bart Scott, as well as defensive coordinator Rex Ryan.
Baltimore could look at cornerback, with last year’s starting combo of McAlister and Samari Rolle, not active in those roles anymore. Vonte Davis, brother of 49ers tight end Vernon Davis, has all the measurements of a prototypical NFL cornerback, but hasn’t showed the instincts scouts would like to see. Baltimore could see an opportunity to bring him in and let him learn behind mentors such as Ed Reed and Ray Lewis, giving him time to pick up the nuances of the game.
27. Indianapolis Colts-Peria Jerry, DT Ole Miss
-The Colts have been run over the past few years and need help at defensive tackle. Wide receiver could be a dark horse after Indy cut future Hall of Famer Marvin Harrison, but the Colts may have planned for that when they drafted Anthony Gonzalez a couple years ago. Peria Jerry is the best DT after BJ Raji, and plays with a different style. While Raji is a space stuffer with excellent strength, Jerry gets pressure up the middle with his quickness and technique. Jerry would fill a major need for the Colts.
28. Buffalo Bills (from Carolina through Philadelphia)-Brandon Pettigrew, TE Oklahoma State
-Word has come out of Bills camp that they will not replace left tackle Jason Peters with the picks they received for him. The Bills could use a tight end, and many mocks had them taking Brandon Pettigrew with the 11th pick. Now that they have two first-round picks, they would love to see him fall the to then end of the first round. Pettigrew is regarded as the top tight end in an underwhelming class, mostly because of his all-around game. While South Carolina’s Jared Cook is a more athletic player, who specializes in the passing game, Pettigrew runs crisp routes and is a much better blocker. Therefore, Pettigrew is a solid, three-down player, who can be used in all formations.
With a suspension looming for running back Marshawn Lynch, the Bills could focus heavily on their passing game next year. After signing Terrell Owens, the Bills could also add a tight end to maximize their options for a young Trent Edwards.
29. New York Giants-Hakeem Nicks, WR UNC
-This pick has been entirely dependent on the Plaxico Burress situation. Without Burress, the Giants are a completely different team, and Eli Manning becomes a much more pedestrian quarterback. Their running game and offensive line are solid, although the loss of Derrick Ward could see the G-Men picking a running back in later rounds. With Burress gone, the Giants will need to invest in the wide receiver position yet again, despite taking Sinorice Moss, Steve Smith and Mario Manningham the past three years. After cutting ties with Amani Toomer, that position is a weakness without their #1 and #2 receivers of last season.
The Giants stacked their defensive line by adding former Dallas Cowboy, Chris Canty, and Osi Umenyiora will return from a torn lateral meniscus that kept him from playing all of last year. Defensive line will probably not be touched in this class. Drafting a linebacker could also be an option, as the Giants haven’t successfully replaced Kawika Mitchell following their Super Bowl-winning season in 2007-8.
30. Tennessee Titans-Alex Mack, C Cal
-The Titans have several needs for playmakers on both sides of the ball. Wide receiver has been an issue that has been overlooked for the past few drafts, and the departure of Albert Haynesworth to the Washington Redskins could require upgrades for both the defensive line and the secondary, who thrived off pressure from just a four-man rush. However, the Titans do like Jason Jones as a potential replacement for Haynesworth, and they could pass on cornerbacks until the second day.
Center Kevin Mawae is becoming ancient and could be viewing retirement after this year. University of California-Berkeley center Alex Mack is one of the best to come along in some time, and his versatility could allow him to play guard until Mawae is gone. The Titans are a team that loves to build through the trenches, even if it means leaving talent lacking on the outsides. Receiver could be an option here but with five already off the board here, the value is decreased. Unless the Titans fall in love with Rutgers WR Kenny Britt, don’t be surprised to see them stick with the lines here.
31. Arizona Cardinals-Connor Barwin, LB Cincinnati
-After a dream run to the Super Bowl last year, the Cardinals are back to build on a successful season. The big question for this pick is, "Will Anquan Boldin be on the roster?" Boldin has been demanding a new deal since last year and publicly expressed his displeasure with the organization. If Boldin is gone, the Cardinals have showed they can go on without him, but would likely need to add other pieces, like another running back or receiving tight end. If he is there, the Cards should look at upgrading the defense.
While Arizona did make it to the Super Bowl, it wasn’t enough to save defensive coordinator Clancy Pendergast’s job, so expect an investment in a few areas before the draft is over. With a solid secondary, the defensive line could use improvements, building around DT Darnell Dockett. Defensive end is a concern, and unless last year’s second-round pick, DE Calais Campbell, has a break-out season, the Cardinals will have whiffed on DT Gabe Watson, DT Alan Branch and Campbell in consecutive years. While it would be painful to use another high pick on those positions, they could take a different approach and go for speed over size. Cincinnati’s Connor Barwin could be a sleeper with this pick, as a big, speedy outside linebacker with the ability to play defensive end. He clocked a 4.47 at the combine and could be the disruption needed from the edge in the Cardinals’ scheme.
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Eben Britton, OT Arizona
-Look for Oregon C Max Unger to possibly be this pick as well. The Steelers have glaring concerns on their offensive line, despite winning the Super Bowl last season. Tackle Marvel Smith departed in free agency, and Willie Colon and Max Starks are not long-term solutions, after franchising Starks and tendering Colon. Center and guard could use improvements as well, which makes Unger a possibility because of his ability to play anywhere on the interior of the line.
Eben Britton would be a good pickup here because of his ability to play on both the left and right sides. As the best of the second tier of tackles, Britton projects to be a solid player at the next level, no matter which side you put him on. The Steelers will likely be in the same position at tackle next year if they don’t address it in this draft, so it would be better to have someone in the system before that time comes. Unger would be a nice selection, but will probably be available in the second round if the Steelers would like to move up to get him. If not, there are other skilled centers in this draft and guards can be found much later than the first round.
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Windy City Dries Eyes of Crybaby
Hey! Wake up little guy! You're moving to Chicago!
The saga NFL Network termed "McJay-Gate" has finally come to an end, after rivers of tears, heavy doses of midol, close insulin monitoring, and the pouting of a 17-year-old girl who wasn't asked to prom. Former Denver Broncos quarterback, Jay Cutler, has been traded to the Chicago Bears along with a 2009 fifth-round draft choice for 2009 and 2010 first-round picks and a 2009 third-round pick.
Sources, always anonymous, "close to the situation" say Washington was a major player until the last minute, when Chicago swooped in and topped the offer. The Redskins were prepared to mortgage their future, just like last year with Chad Ocho Cinco, offering two first-round picks and current quarterback Jason Campbell. The sources say the Broncos didn't want Jason Campbell, preferring Kyle Orton, which is why the deal fell apart.
Redskins fans, please trust me, this is a blessing in disguise. From experience, I can tell you there is nothing worse than a soft southerner with diabetes. If Cutler can act like that in Denver, he can act like that in Washington. Instead of using the failed Matt Cassel trade as motivation to better himself and prove his worth to his new coach, he folded up shop and reverse-manifest destinied his way East.
Fans in D.C. are all too aware of the short fuse Redskins owner Dan Snyder has with players and coaches, and all it could take is one or two rough seasons before he's looking at other options for starting quarterback. Snyder showed he has no problem being open about it, as he publicly put Campbell on the trading block, and tried to package him in the move for Cutler. When the trade failed, he brought Byron Leftwich in for a tryout. He previously ditched Brad Johnson for Jeff George, and George was gone within a year after that. What's to say Snyder wouldn't have done the same with Cutler? Apparently all it takes is a whisper for Cutler to throw a tantrum, so what happens when he hears about the Colt Brennan phenomenon in D.C.?
What the Redskins desperately need, is to rebuild both of their lines. That wasn't going to happen if two first-round picks were traded away, maybe a third-round pick as well. By hanging on to those picks (for now), the Skins can draft an offensive tackle and a defensive lineman with those first-round selections. They could pick up an interior offensive lineman with the third-round choice as well.The Redskins have loaded up on defense and have a heavy run game installed in the offense. While quarterback is important, it's more important that he's provided protection with an improved line. If the Skins stay as they are for next season, it won't matter who the quarterback is, he'll be on his back constantly.
Campbell is in a contract year. He can play lights out and get an extension if he shows he's your franchise guy. If he falls flat, you can let him walk with no penalty. Keeping those first-round picks will benefit this team down the road, if used properly, and the Redskins can get younger on both sides of the ball. While Cutler was the flashy choice, he would have come at too big of a price. The Redskins should be happy they were able to get away from this one. They should take a page out of Cutler's book, stay away from the sweets.
Sunday, March 22, 2009
My Obsession with "The U"
Since the passing of Sean Taylor, I have been wildly fascinated by the University of Miami teams put together at the turn of the century. With so many first-round draft picks, they were absolutely loaded and lost many players early to the NFL draft. Taking a full, four-year sample of recruits, I love looking at what this team could have been if everyone played together. Taking the players compiled from 2000-2003, this is easily the greatest grouping of talent college football has ever seen.
Your 2000-2003 roster:QB:
Ken Dorsey
RB:
Clinton Portis
Willis McGahee
Frank Gore
Najeh Davenport
WR:
Reggie Wayne
Andre Johnson
Santana Moss
Roscoe Parrish
Sinorice Moss
TE:
Jeremy Shockey
Kellen Winslow II
Greg Olsen
Tackle:
Bryant McKinnie
Vernon Carey
Eric Winston
Joaquin Gonzalez
Guard:
Martin Bibla
Sherko Haji-Rasouli
Center:
Brett Romberg
DE:Jerome McDougale
Baraka Atkins
Bryan Pata
DT:
Vince Wilfork
Orien Harris
William Joseph
LB:
Jonathan Vilma
D.J. Williams
Jon Beason
Dan Morgan
Rocky McIntosh
Leon Williams
CB:
Antrel Rolle
Phillip Buchanon
Kelly Jennings
Al Blades
Safety:
Sean Taylor
Ed Reed
Brandon Meriweather
Punt/Kick Returner:
Devin Hester
That roster blows my mind. You seriously had to be a future Pro Bowler just to see the field on that team. I would love to see that squad put back together and matched against an NFL team, because I honestly think the University of Miami would win. There might not be a collection of talent like that on a college team ever again.
Monday, March 9, 2009
Annoying Phrases in Sports Broadcasting
After hearing non-stop stories about Rush Limbaugh for the past few weeks, I got to thinking about lots of things that annoy me with a certain amount of frequency. When it comes to sports, I find it very annoying when announcers in the booth or anchors in the studio constantly say things incorrectly or consistenly use cliches. It seems not many of them do any sort of personal research or commit anything to memory. Moreover, many just copy what others do, lacking originality and lessening the product of the broadcast, detracting from the game you're watching to the point of not being able to pay attention to the action.
I have compiled a list of sayings I would like to do without for the upcoming season. Frankly, I'd like to see them gone forever.
Phrase: "Manny being Manny"
Status: Annoying, played out
Reason: Manny Ramirez is both annoying and played out. In an age of steroids and performance-enhancing drugs, this player actually chooses to be the laziest athlete in the game. He demands more money than he's worth and only plays when he feels like it. His fielding is terrible, but he hits a fair amount of home runs a year, so he's apparently worth more than $20 million per season.
Suggestion: Replace with, "Oh look, he's living up to his potential!"
Phrase: "Matriculate the ball down the field"
Status: Improper, pompous
Reason: The definition of the word "matriculate," per the dictionary, is "to enroll at a college or university as a candidate for a degree." Can anyone explain how teams are expected to "enroll in college down the field?" Overall, this phrase is used more by analysts than color commentators, meaning it is mostly said by former players and coaches. My gut tells me an intern thought he knew a big word, but was mistaken, and told the analyst to say it on the air to sound smart. Unfortunately, the word became popular and was never researched. It has now been adopted into the uneducated expert's football lexicon.
Suggestion: Buy a dictionary and understand the words coming out of your mouth.
Phrase: "Literally"
Status: Improper, unnecessary
Reason: The actual word "literally" is not the issue here, but rather how it is used, which is usually incorrectly. When applying "literally" to a statement, you are saying that whatever it is actually happened that way, or that you are not exaggerating in any way, meaning no hyperbole or metaphor. My absolute favorite has to be ESPN analyst Rod Gilmore's take on Wisconsin's young offensive line, composed mainly of freshmen at the time, referring to them as, "literally infants out there."
Suggestion: Take a grammar course, maybe go back to middle school altogether.
Phrase: "Paydirt"
Status: Overused, played out
Reason: I have heard this used for some time, but it has recently caught fire, used at every turn. The word "paydirt" has effectively taken the place of the word "touchdown" in the NFL. This phrase, championed by Greg Gumbel, has now spread to the likes of James Brown, Curt Menefee, and even Joe Buck. Sometimes you just want to hear the actual term, "touchdown."
Suggestion: While this phrase hasn't become totally annoying yet, it is widely overused. It needs to be scaled back, only sprinkled into broadcasts. This phrase should be equated to the hunting of an endangered species, halted immediately, only to return when the status is healthy and able to be dealt with in a responsible manner.
Phrase: "Adversity"
Status: Cliche, played out
Reason: No one has thought of a replacement for the word "adversity" in decades. In fact, the term "adversity" has spread into all facets of analysis when referring to any sport. This has put a damper on intelligent conversation and decreased the credibility of former players who become analysts. Adversity is commonly used during preseason, when teams are mostly healthy. A broadcaster might ask an analyst on a talk show, "What does this team need to be successful this season?" The analysts' response will often not deviate from something along the lines of, "Well, it's all about how this team handles adversity."
Suggestion: Find a new word, it's called a thesaurus. In two seconds, I found synonyms such as: catastrophe, distress, ill fortune, tough luck, trial and affliction. Feel free to use any of those or go find your own.
I have compiled a list of sayings I would like to do without for the upcoming season. Frankly, I'd like to see them gone forever.
Phrase: "Manny being Manny"
Status: Annoying, played out
Reason: Manny Ramirez is both annoying and played out. In an age of steroids and performance-enhancing drugs, this player actually chooses to be the laziest athlete in the game. He demands more money than he's worth and only plays when he feels like it. His fielding is terrible, but he hits a fair amount of home runs a year, so he's apparently worth more than $20 million per season.
Suggestion: Replace with, "Oh look, he's living up to his potential!"
Phrase: "Matriculate the ball down the field"
Status: Improper, pompous
Reason: The definition of the word "matriculate," per the dictionary, is "to enroll at a college or university as a candidate for a degree." Can anyone explain how teams are expected to "enroll in college down the field?" Overall, this phrase is used more by analysts than color commentators, meaning it is mostly said by former players and coaches. My gut tells me an intern thought he knew a big word, but was mistaken, and told the analyst to say it on the air to sound smart. Unfortunately, the word became popular and was never researched. It has now been adopted into the uneducated expert's football lexicon.
Suggestion: Buy a dictionary and understand the words coming out of your mouth.
Phrase: "Literally"
Status: Improper, unnecessary
Reason: The actual word "literally" is not the issue here, but rather how it is used, which is usually incorrectly. When applying "literally" to a statement, you are saying that whatever it is actually happened that way, or that you are not exaggerating in any way, meaning no hyperbole or metaphor. My absolute favorite has to be ESPN analyst Rod Gilmore's take on Wisconsin's young offensive line, composed mainly of freshmen at the time, referring to them as, "literally infants out there."
Suggestion: Take a grammar course, maybe go back to middle school altogether.
Phrase: "Paydirt"
Status: Overused, played out
Reason: I have heard this used for some time, but it has recently caught fire, used at every turn. The word "paydirt" has effectively taken the place of the word "touchdown" in the NFL. This phrase, championed by Greg Gumbel, has now spread to the likes of James Brown, Curt Menefee, and even Joe Buck. Sometimes you just want to hear the actual term, "touchdown."
Suggestion: While this phrase hasn't become totally annoying yet, it is widely overused. It needs to be scaled back, only sprinkled into broadcasts. This phrase should be equated to the hunting of an endangered species, halted immediately, only to return when the status is healthy and able to be dealt with in a responsible manner.
Phrase: "Adversity"
Status: Cliche, played out
Reason: No one has thought of a replacement for the word "adversity" in decades. In fact, the term "adversity" has spread into all facets of analysis when referring to any sport. This has put a damper on intelligent conversation and decreased the credibility of former players who become analysts. Adversity is commonly used during preseason, when teams are mostly healthy. A broadcaster might ask an analyst on a talk show, "What does this team need to be successful this season?" The analysts' response will often not deviate from something along the lines of, "Well, it's all about how this team handles adversity."
Suggestion: Find a new word, it's called a thesaurus. In two seconds, I found synonyms such as: catastrophe, distress, ill fortune, tough luck, trial and affliction. Feel free to use any of those or go find your own.
Phrase: "Where we're at"
Status: Improper, wildly popular
Reason: This phrase has become so broadly accepted, I'm not sure if people know this is incorrect anymore. It's not just athletes, it's pop culture and the youth who are influenced by it. I constantly hear things like, "Where you at?" or "Where is he at?" In sports, I now hear coaches and players say on a regular basis that they need to, "see where we're at" when they lose a tough game and need to watch the tape. I wonder if people know it's actually easier and shorter to say, "Where we are" or "Where is he?"
Suggestion: Actually listen to the comments you make when they playback on television, I think you'll notice how bad you sound as soon as you hear it.
All I want to see is some originality on television, someone please break the mold. It's not difficult, all you have to do is a little research, maybe even log onto the internet once or twice. Please, if anyone is listening, tell these announcers and analysts to put some effort into what they are doing and to do some fact checking as well. Here's to a prosperous and knowledgeable football season!
All I want to see is some originality on television, someone please break the mold. It's not difficult, all you have to do is a little research, maybe even log onto the internet once or twice. Please, if anyone is listening, tell these announcers and analysts to put some effort into what they are doing and to do some fact checking as well. Here's to a prosperous and knowledgeable football season!
Wednesday, March 4, 2009
Shout Out to Tim Tebow
Heisman trophy winner and two-time national champion Tim Tebow just found a larger place in my heart after hanging out with my family in Gainesville. Tebow stopped by my cousin's soccer tournament near the University of Florida, apparently because he is a family friend of one of her teammates. Tebow not only took the time to watch the games and cheer them on, sign autographs and take pictures, including the one above with my cousin Jordan, but he gave the entire team and families a personal tour of the University of Florida's athletic facilities, football stadium and trophy room. He was described as "incredibly gracious" and personable, joking around with everyone and making himself accessible to all of the guests. Thank you Tim Tebow, it's great to hear that someone who is lauded so much in the media, is actually that terrific of a person in real life.
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Making Offseason Plans
With the NFL Combine now finished and free agency starting in just over 24 hours, it's time for me to finally unveil what I'd do with this team if I was owner and general manager. I now have an idea of who I want to draft and who will go where, so before everything falls into place in reality, I'll reveal what I'd do if given the opportunity.Priorities
1. Revamp both lines. It' s been far too long since we've invested in any position on both lines via the draft and the time is now. This team has to get younger, especially in the trenches, and cannot afford to go another year without addressing the issue. This year's draft needs to be devoted to improving the core of this team and injecting some youth.
2. Cut dead weight. There are far too many past-prime, overpaid players on this team and cuts need to be made. I doubt there is a trade market for most of the players we need to jettison, so without belaboring the issue, it's time to just part ways and move forward, addition by subtraction.
3. Keep the quarterback position open. If Jason Campbell is really the future of this franchise, he should have no problem holding off a 37-year-old who has only played a handful of games in the last decade and last year's sixth-round pick. If Colt Brennan is the gun-slinging, swag-dripping rockstar many think he is, then he should emerge and find his way onto the field. Training camp would begin fresh, with nothing settled on the QB depth chart and everything to play for.
4. Hold onto draft picks and plan for the future. A single trade should not be made this offseason that results in us losing draft picks. Everything should be done in free agency and the draft. This team must keep picks to stay young, cost-effective and developing. That plan starts immediately with no more back-breaking, salary-cap-crippling aquisitions that set the organization back three or four years.
Salary Cap and Cuts
This team is over the salary cap every year and instead of learning from their mistakes or cutting our free agent blunders, the front office always just restructures contracts of aging players, guaranteeing them more money upfront and extending their contracts so money can be spread over a longer period of time. Going into next year, we are again over the cap and need to make cuts to sign draft picks and any free agents brought in. The front office has already restructured Andre Carter, Antwaan Randle El and Chris Samuels, saving close to $10 million in cap space for next year, but mortgaging the future for the present. Let's call it even with the restructuring and the figure over the cap and say the Redskins are now breaking even.
I would start at the top of the payroll and work my way down, looking to cut anyone whose pay doesn't match their production or whomever cannot perform at a high level anymore. The players cut, in order of money saved:
$8.5 million-Jason Taylor
$6 million-Shawn Springs
$4.5 million-Marcus Washington
$2.3 million-Phillip Daniels
$845,000-James Thrash
$535,000-Ryan Plackemeier
$535,000-Will Montgomery
$535,000-D'Anthony Batiste
$460,000-Alex Buzbee
An immediate savings of $24.21 million towards the cap.
That $24+ million will be used to sign a couple necessary free agents, our draft picks and re-sign our own free agents.
Re-Signings
Before free agency, we'd have the opportunity to retain our own players before they hit the open market. The list of players I'd bring back:
DeAngelo Hall CB
Demetric Evans DE
Kedric Golston DT
Anthony Montgomery DT
Ethan Albright LS
Alfred Fincher LB
Khary Campbell LB
Reed Doughty SS
Pete Kendall OG
Of that group, only Hall would command serious money and a long-term deal. The rest would provide good depth and special teams contributions, not to mention they would come cheap.
Free Agency
Channing Crowder LB
Mike Furrey WR
While there are some big time players out there, it would be nice to remain quiet in free agency. However, there are some intriguing prospects that could fill holes left by salary cap casualties. Offensive and defensive lines are a concern, as well as strongside linebacker.
However, attempting to stay away from the free agent disasters of the past, the only real consideration I'd give to signing an immediate starter is linebacker Channing Crowder. He has been a tackling machine and has a nasty attitude that would fit perfectly with the NFC East. He is durable and versatile, giving us the option to put him at strongside in the 4-3 as opposed to the inside role he was playing in Miami's 3-4. He's reliable, energetic and has a clean record off the field.
Mike Furrey is a solid possession receiver who could help out when needed, especially if Malcolm Kelly can't get on the field again. Furrey is a poor man's Wes Welker, small with average speed, but runs great routes and isn't scared to get hit.
The Draft
The Skins only have first-, third-, fifth- and sixth-round picks in the draft, so it's important to key in on what's important and where you can get the most value. While both lines are a priority, reaching for a player can hurt if you pass on a superstar. That said, I wouldn't touch the skill positions of this team, unless someone amazing fell to me. The secondary on this team is set, the running backs are fine for another year, the quarterback needs to be given another year, and three pass catchers were taken in last year's draft. We'd draft:
1. Michael Oher-OT, Ole Miss
3. Kraig Urbik-OG, Wisconsin
5. Jasper Brinkley-LB, South Carolina
6. Mitch King-DE/DT, Iowa
The Redskins are in a bit of a tough spot at #13. The ideal pick would be offensive lineman Eugene Monroe from Virginia, but he'll likely be a top two pick. Baylor's Jason Smith could also be a consideration at right tackle, but will likely be gone, as will Boston College defensive tackle B.J. Raji and Texas' defensive end Brian Orakpo.
Oher is a little bit risky, but has the physical skillset to play at the next level. Mix that with line coach Joe Bugel's know-how, and I think he'll be solid. Bugel made undrafted Stephon Heyer into the starter at right tackle last year, so you can imagine what the possibilities are with a first-round pick.
Urbik is a roughneck who can provide interior help in the run game. Last year's third-round pick Chad Rinehart doesn't appear to be ready for the NFL yet, so he can't be counted on to start next year. Urbik should have the opportunity to start at left guard with Pete Kendall aging and arthritic.
Brinkley is one of the largest linebackers you'll ever see. He checks in at about 270-275 lbs. playing middle linebacker. His size could allow him to move to strongside on running downs and he can lay a serious hit. Brinkley and H.B. Blades could be interchangeable as backups on the inside and outside and could be the future of the corps.
King would hope to be the utility guy on the defensive line. At around 280 lbs., he's not a genuine defensive tackle, but could play inside on passing downs to rush the quarterback. However, being that big could make him a run stuffer on the end, allowing linebackers to roam free. Best case scenario, he'd be a Justin Tuck-type for the Skins, worst case, he's another young body to throw in the mix.
Roster Breakdown
Offense
QB: (open competition)
Starter: Jason Campbell
Backups: #2 Colt Brennan/#3 Todd Collins
FB:
Mike Sellers
RB:
Starter: Clinton Portis
Backups: Ladell Betts/Rock Cartwright
LT:
Starter: Chris Samuels
Backup: Stephon Heyer
LG:
Starter: Kraig Urbik
Backup: Pete Kendall
C:
Starter: Casey Rabach
Backup: Training camp battle
RG:
Starter: Randy Thomas
Backup: Chad Rinehart
RT:
Starter: Michael Oher
Backup: Jon Jansen
TE:
Starter: Chris Cooley
Backups: Todd Yoder, Fred Davis
WR 1:
Starter: Santana Moss
Backup: Malcolm Kelly
WR 2:
Starter: Devin Thomas
Backup: Antwaan Randle El
Slot WRs: Antwaan Randle El, Malcolm Kelly, Mike Furrey
Defense
RE:
Starter: Andre Carter
Backup: Chris Wilson/Rob Jackson
DT:
Starter: Cornelius Griffin
Backups: Kedric Golston/Lorenzo Alexander
DT:
Starter: Anthony Montgomery
Backups: Kedric Golston/Mitch King
LE:
Starter: Demetric Evans
Backup: Mitch King/Rob Jackson
WLB:
Starter: Rocky McIntosh
Backups: H.B. Blades/Alfred Fincher
MLB:
Starter: London Fletcher
Backups: H.B. Blades/Jasper Brinkley
SLB:
Starter: Channing Crowder
Backups: Khary Campbell/Jasper Brinkley
CB 1:
Starter: Carlos Rogers
Backup: Fred Smoot
CB 2:
Starter: DeAngelo Hall
Backup: J.T. Tryon
Nickel CB: Fred Smoot
FS:
Starter: LaRon Landry
Backup: Kareem Moore
SS:
Starter: Chris Horton
Backup: Reed Doughty
Returners:
Kickoffs: Rock Cartwright
Punts: Dominique Dorsey
Kicker: Open competition
Punter: Open competition
Of course, this process isn't complete and this team is still a couple years away from not just being a contender, but molded in a different way, with a new mindset. The following year, a few more big contracts would have to be dumped and more draft picks would have to go into the lines. However, this is just the start. The overhaul isn't finished and would continue though the years. It would also give some young, late-round picks the opportunity to step up and see some legitimate playing time, possibly being the next Chris Horton as an absolute draft steal.
The blueprint has been laid out. Starting inside and moving our way out will keep this team young and deep, adding pieces over the years to get us to the next level.
Sunday, February 22, 2009
Possible Silver Lining in the Jason Taylor Trade
As free agency approaches and teams assess their needs for the upcoming season, many franchises find themselves looking for cap space to make moves and cutting players with hefty, undesirable contracts to make their wish lists possible. The Washington Redskins annually fall into that category, and have begun the process by restructuring the contracts of defensive end Andre Carter and wide receiver Antwaan Randle El, freeing up around $4 million in cap room for next season. However, those moves alone do not get the Redskins under the salary cap and cuts or more restructurings will be necessary to comply.
Washington has a handful of aging players whose absorbitant contracts are not matching the production expected from them on the field. At the forefront of that list is defensive end Jason Taylor. While Taylor more than likely will be headed to the Hall of Fame, he is also headed towards 35, and will make $8.5 million dollars next season despite missing most of last year with knee and calf injuries. Taylor will be the second highest-paid player on the roster, $800,000 behind Pro Bowl left tackle Chris Samules.
Taylor was acquired from the Miami Dolphins when starting defensive end Phillip Daniels tore his ACL the first day of training camp. That afternoon, Washington sent a 2009 second-round draft pick, as well as a sixth-round pick in 2010. However, because Taylor was brought in via trade, the Redskins can cut him without taking on any dead cap from his contract. Taylor is scheduled to make $8.5 million next year, but by cutting him, the Redskins could save all of the $8.5 million and use that money elsewhere.
While I know many Redskins fans were not supporters of the Taylor trade, myself included, there is a chance for redemption. Look at it this way, by cutting Taylor right now, the Redskins traded second- and sixth-round picks for $8.5 million in free agency money. Washington does need to get younger as a whole, so trading away draft picks isn't the right direction to take, but what's done is done so putting the best spin on it helps.
Jason Taylor has been a phenomenal player for the last decade, but the Redskins traded for him in the twilight of his career and it's time to cut its losses. Using his salary in free agency to bring in two or three players at positions of need will be much more valuable than overpaying a player past his prime for one last go-round.
Washington has a handful of aging players whose absorbitant contracts are not matching the production expected from them on the field. At the forefront of that list is defensive end Jason Taylor. While Taylor more than likely will be headed to the Hall of Fame, he is also headed towards 35, and will make $8.5 million dollars next season despite missing most of last year with knee and calf injuries. Taylor will be the second highest-paid player on the roster, $800,000 behind Pro Bowl left tackle Chris Samules.
Taylor was acquired from the Miami Dolphins when starting defensive end Phillip Daniels tore his ACL the first day of training camp. That afternoon, Washington sent a 2009 second-round draft pick, as well as a sixth-round pick in 2010. However, because Taylor was brought in via trade, the Redskins can cut him without taking on any dead cap from his contract. Taylor is scheduled to make $8.5 million next year, but by cutting him, the Redskins could save all of the $8.5 million and use that money elsewhere.
While I know many Redskins fans were not supporters of the Taylor trade, myself included, there is a chance for redemption. Look at it this way, by cutting Taylor right now, the Redskins traded second- and sixth-round picks for $8.5 million in free agency money. Washington does need to get younger as a whole, so trading away draft picks isn't the right direction to take, but what's done is done so putting the best spin on it helps.
Jason Taylor has been a phenomenal player for the last decade, but the Redskins traded for him in the twilight of his career and it's time to cut its losses. Using his salary in free agency to bring in two or three players at positions of need will be much more valuable than overpaying a player past his prime for one last go-round.
Friday, February 20, 2009
I Love Steve Spurrier
After reviewing Lane Kiffin's less than stellar start at Tennessee, I got to thinking about the comments made by opposing SEC coaches about him and the overall trash talking done around the league. The first person that comes to mind is Steve Spurrier. Without a doubt, he is the ultimate coach when it comes to the gift of gab. I'm a huge Washington Redskins and Florida Gators fan, as well as an alumnus from the University of South Carolina. I have followed him my whole life and have loved him at each of those coaching stops.
Paying homage to "The Ole Ball Coach," here are some of my favorite quotes from "The Visor":
On Florida beating Tennessee every year, resulting in the Vols multiple Citrus Bowl appearances in the 90s: "You can't spell Citrus without UT."
On Peyton Manning returning to Tennessee for his senior year: "I know why Peyton came back for his senior year, he wanted to be a 3-time Citrus Bowl MVP."
On Florida State's lack of institutional control with their players: "You know what FSU stands for, don't you? Free Shoes University."
On a fire in an Auburn dorm room that burned, among other things, 20 books: "The real tragedy was that 15 hadn't been colored in yet."
On whether Florida would beat Georgia that particular season: "I don't know. Is Ray Goff still the head coach there?" (Spurrier was 6-0 against Goff, often referring to him as Ray Goof)
On Florida's 52-17 victory over Georgia in Athens, 1995: "We knew coming in nobody had scored 50 against them here, so that's what we wanted to do. This may be the only time in our lifetime that Florida plays here, so we wanted to make it memorable for the Gators."
On Georgia's recruiting after a 45-13 win in 1991 over the Bulldogs: "Why is it that during recruiting season they sign all the great players, but when it comes time to play the game, we have all the great players? I don't understand that. What happens to them?"
Regarding his nickname for Ben Hill Griffin Stadium: "The Swamp is where Gators live. We feel comfortable there, but we hope our opponents feel tentative. A swamp is hot and sticky and can be dangerous." (Hence, "The Swamp" was born)
On recruiting from the state of Alabama during the Crimson Tide's era of scholarship violations: "In 12 years at Florida, I don't think we ever signed a kid from the state of Alabama. Of course, we found out later that the scholarships they were giving out at Alabama were worth a whole lot more than ours."
On whether coaching would be more difficult in the NFL than college: "Yes, because there are no Vanderbilts in the NFL."
After beating Mississippi State 52-0: "Their pass defense was number one in the nation coming in, but it won't be going out."
After winning the SEC championship: "This is our annual team picture."
After beating Ohio State in the national championship in both football and basketball: "We've kind of turned Ohio State into Runner-Up U, haven't we?"
After being called "classless" by North Carolina coach Mack Brown for bringing his Duke team back onto the field for a team photo in front of the scoreboard after a win in Chapel Hill: "Why? I've got a better record on that field than he does."
Finally the best story I've ever heard about Spurrier and his recruiting, taken from his biography by Bill Chastain:
"McGriff went to a weight-lifting competition held at the school where he encountered Spurrier.
'Steve didn't like weight-lifting at all,' McGriff said. 'I didn't know he was going to be there. We show up at the same time. I see him in his casual way.'
Spurrier: Hey, how you been, whatcha gonna do? You gonna watch this weight-lifting thing? You like that?
McGriff: No, I don't really, I like to work out and all that, but I don't know that I want to watch this competition. But I'm going to do it, because that's what the guy's doing and he's going to see me.
Spurrier: Then whatcha gonna do?
McGriff: Well, hopefully, I'll see him, then I'll be back at the school tomorrow.
Spurrier: Well, I really don't like this stuff. Whatcha wearing a tie for?
McGriff: Well, I won't wear this to every high school. If I'm in Pahokee, I don't have this on. Or if I go to Tampa Plant High School, I don't have this on. But I'm here at Cardinal Mooney.
Spurrier: I don't like to wear ties. I don't know, I don't think I'm going to watch this stuff. I'll see you in a little while.
Spurrier retrieved his workout clothes from his car and changed in the Cardinal Mooney locker room.
'He goes out there with the Cardinal Mooney baseball team and starts shagging flies,' McGriff said. 'He doesn't see shit for the weight-lifting thing. So the great part of the story is, somehow he's got his car keys, but he stayed out shagging flies for so long that he gets locked out from his clothes. He can't get them out. Well, he had a home visit that night. He goes to this boy's home. Shows up, he'd been sweating, because it's May, it's hot. He doesn't have a shirt on. This boy comes home and there's Steve Spurrier sitting on his couch, on a towel, no shirt on, drinking a beer with the guy's dad. And of course, I know Steve, and I'm laughing my brains out the next day when Steve is telling me this story. Then I see somebody else who confirmed the story. Well, I'm working my butt off to sign my guy. I don't sign him. You think Steve signed his guy? He did.'"
Paying homage to "The Ole Ball Coach," here are some of my favorite quotes from "The Visor":
On Florida beating Tennessee every year, resulting in the Vols multiple Citrus Bowl appearances in the 90s: "You can't spell Citrus without UT."
On Peyton Manning returning to Tennessee for his senior year: "I know why Peyton came back for his senior year, he wanted to be a 3-time Citrus Bowl MVP."
On Florida State's lack of institutional control with their players: "You know what FSU stands for, don't you? Free Shoes University."
On a fire in an Auburn dorm room that burned, among other things, 20 books: "The real tragedy was that 15 hadn't been colored in yet."
On whether Florida would beat Georgia that particular season: "I don't know. Is Ray Goff still the head coach there?" (Spurrier was 6-0 against Goff, often referring to him as Ray Goof)
On Florida's 52-17 victory over Georgia in Athens, 1995: "We knew coming in nobody had scored 50 against them here, so that's what we wanted to do. This may be the only time in our lifetime that Florida plays here, so we wanted to make it memorable for the Gators."
On Georgia's recruiting after a 45-13 win in 1991 over the Bulldogs: "Why is it that during recruiting season they sign all the great players, but when it comes time to play the game, we have all the great players? I don't understand that. What happens to them?"
Regarding his nickname for Ben Hill Griffin Stadium: "The Swamp is where Gators live. We feel comfortable there, but we hope our opponents feel tentative. A swamp is hot and sticky and can be dangerous." (Hence, "The Swamp" was born)
On recruiting from the state of Alabama during the Crimson Tide's era of scholarship violations: "In 12 years at Florida, I don't think we ever signed a kid from the state of Alabama. Of course, we found out later that the scholarships they were giving out at Alabama were worth a whole lot more than ours."
On whether coaching would be more difficult in the NFL than college: "Yes, because there are no Vanderbilts in the NFL."
After beating Mississippi State 52-0: "Their pass defense was number one in the nation coming in, but it won't be going out."
After winning the SEC championship: "This is our annual team picture."
After beating Ohio State in the national championship in both football and basketball: "We've kind of turned Ohio State into Runner-Up U, haven't we?"
After being called "classless" by North Carolina coach Mack Brown for bringing his Duke team back onto the field for a team photo in front of the scoreboard after a win in Chapel Hill: "Why? I've got a better record on that field than he does."
Finally the best story I've ever heard about Spurrier and his recruiting, taken from his biography by Bill Chastain:
"McGriff went to a weight-lifting competition held at the school where he encountered Spurrier.
'Steve didn't like weight-lifting at all,' McGriff said. 'I didn't know he was going to be there. We show up at the same time. I see him in his casual way.'
Spurrier: Hey, how you been, whatcha gonna do? You gonna watch this weight-lifting thing? You like that?
McGriff: No, I don't really, I like to work out and all that, but I don't know that I want to watch this competition. But I'm going to do it, because that's what the guy's doing and he's going to see me.
Spurrier: Then whatcha gonna do?
McGriff: Well, hopefully, I'll see him, then I'll be back at the school tomorrow.
Spurrier: Well, I really don't like this stuff. Whatcha wearing a tie for?
McGriff: Well, I won't wear this to every high school. If I'm in Pahokee, I don't have this on. Or if I go to Tampa Plant High School, I don't have this on. But I'm here at Cardinal Mooney.
Spurrier: I don't like to wear ties. I don't know, I don't think I'm going to watch this stuff. I'll see you in a little while.
Spurrier retrieved his workout clothes from his car and changed in the Cardinal Mooney locker room.
'He goes out there with the Cardinal Mooney baseball team and starts shagging flies,' McGriff said. 'He doesn't see shit for the weight-lifting thing. So the great part of the story is, somehow he's got his car keys, but he stayed out shagging flies for so long that he gets locked out from his clothes. He can't get them out. Well, he had a home visit that night. He goes to this boy's home. Shows up, he'd been sweating, because it's May, it's hot. He doesn't have a shirt on. This boy comes home and there's Steve Spurrier sitting on his couch, on a towel, no shirt on, drinking a beer with the guy's dad. And of course, I know Steve, and I'm laughing my brains out the next day when Steve is telling me this story. Then I see somebody else who confirmed the story. Well, I'm working my butt off to sign my guy. I don't sign him. You think Steve signed his guy? He did.'"
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Kiffin Volunteers to be an Idiot
Without coaching a single game yet, Tennessee head coach Lane Kiffin has bull's eyes coming at him from all different directions. After attempting to turn the current national champions in for cheating and trying to raid every rivals' coaching staff, Kiffin has now committed several NCAA recruiting violations and stirred up some serious ill will for Citrus, I mean Rocky, Top.
The problems started for Kiffin the first day he got the job. South Carolina head coach, the master of trash talk, Steve Spurrier, suggested Kiffin might have committed a recruiting violation by calling a recruit before he was authorized to do so by the NCAA. Kiffin says he was authorized to make phone calls, and did so to his prized recruit, top-ranked receiver Marlon Brown, who eventually committed to Georgia. Ouch.
Since then, Kiffin has made several more missteps. Kiffin said Florida head coach Urban Meyer cheated in the recruiting process by contacting wide receiver Nu'Keese Richardson while he was on an official visit to Tennessee. Kiffin made two mistakes on that public announcement:
1. What Urban Meyer did was not a recruiting violation.
2. What Kiffin did by talking about it in public was a violation.
"Coach Kiffin has violated the Southeastern Conference Code of Ethics," SEC commissioner Mike Slive said in a statement. "SEC Bylaw 10.5.1 clearly states that coaches and administrators shall refrain from directed public criticism of other member institutions, their staffs or players."
Not only did Kiffin not know the rules of violations by falsely accusing another coach, he ended up committing a violation himself. Ouch.
Later that week, Tennessee announced it was going to self-report more violations committed by Kiffin to avoid further punishment from the NCAA. The first of the new wrongdoings was during a recruiting visit at Tennessee where nine recruits participated in a mock press conference at the university's media center. The second violation was the use of a fog machine for a recruit's entrance to Neyland Stadium. Both of these violated NCAA recruiting rules, which prohibit simulating a game experience for recruits during official visits. Ouch.
The week after that, Kiffin ran into trouble again for referring to an unsigned recruit by name on a local Knoxville radio show. Kiffin talked about Bryce Brown, a Rivals.com five-star running back, who reneged on his verbal commitment to the University of Miami and is considering playing professionally in Canada before going to the NFL. What made it worse was before asking questions, the radio host told Kiffin he couldn't refer to specific recruits by name. Ouch.
Not only has Kiffin shot himself in the foot several times, he has also made quick enemies with some of his top competitors. After Spurrier's recruiting accusations, Kiffin lured Spurrier's brother-in-law, David Reaves, off the South Carolina staff to Tennessee. The Ole' Ball Coach certainly won't forget about that one.
Despite accusing Florida of cheating, Kiffin allegedly went after the Gators' receivers coach, Billy Gonzales, while Florida was preparing for the national championship game. However, Gonzales did not take the job. Ouch.
Kiffin then went after Forbes magazine's most powerful man in sports, Alabama head coach Nick Saban, hiring Lance Thompson, one of Alabama's best recruiters. Maybe Thompson can go over the rules with Kiffin one more time. Saban has since asked all of his committed recruits to not take visits to Tennessee.
Finally, Georgia head coach Mark Richt bested Kiffin once again. Not only did he snag Marlon Brown, Tennessee's number one recruit, he also kept one of the Bulldogs' best recruiters from going to Knoxville. Kiffin offered recruiter Rodney Garner a $400,000 bonus to join the Volunteers, but he turned it down, choosing to stay in Athens. Ouch.
Kiffin can try all he wants to bring some excitement to Rocky Top, even if it means ruffling a few feathers while rebuilding the program. However, he needs to understand what he's doing in the big picture. He has now made himself the biggest target in the SEC next year, and he doesn't really have the firepower to thwart the attack. We've seen what Urban Meyer can do when he wants to seek revenge. We've seen how motivated Mark Richt can get his team. We've seen how surgical Nick Saban can be when the Tide rolls. Next year, Tennessee goes to the Swamp and Tuscaloosa. Georgia and South Carolina will come to Knoxville. Don't expect any house warming gifts.
The problems started for Kiffin the first day he got the job. South Carolina head coach, the master of trash talk, Steve Spurrier, suggested Kiffin might have committed a recruiting violation by calling a recruit before he was authorized to do so by the NCAA. Kiffin says he was authorized to make phone calls, and did so to his prized recruit, top-ranked receiver Marlon Brown, who eventually committed to Georgia. Ouch.
Since then, Kiffin has made several more missteps. Kiffin said Florida head coach Urban Meyer cheated in the recruiting process by contacting wide receiver Nu'Keese Richardson while he was on an official visit to Tennessee. Kiffin made two mistakes on that public announcement:
1. What Urban Meyer did was not a recruiting violation.
2. What Kiffin did by talking about it in public was a violation.
"Coach Kiffin has violated the Southeastern Conference Code of Ethics," SEC commissioner Mike Slive said in a statement. "SEC Bylaw 10.5.1 clearly states that coaches and administrators shall refrain from directed public criticism of other member institutions, their staffs or players."
Not only did Kiffin not know the rules of violations by falsely accusing another coach, he ended up committing a violation himself. Ouch.
Later that week, Tennessee announced it was going to self-report more violations committed by Kiffin to avoid further punishment from the NCAA. The first of the new wrongdoings was during a recruiting visit at Tennessee where nine recruits participated in a mock press conference at the university's media center. The second violation was the use of a fog machine for a recruit's entrance to Neyland Stadium. Both of these violated NCAA recruiting rules, which prohibit simulating a game experience for recruits during official visits. Ouch.
The week after that, Kiffin ran into trouble again for referring to an unsigned recruit by name on a local Knoxville radio show. Kiffin talked about Bryce Brown, a Rivals.com five-star running back, who reneged on his verbal commitment to the University of Miami and is considering playing professionally in Canada before going to the NFL. What made it worse was before asking questions, the radio host told Kiffin he couldn't refer to specific recruits by name. Ouch.
Not only has Kiffin shot himself in the foot several times, he has also made quick enemies with some of his top competitors. After Spurrier's recruiting accusations, Kiffin lured Spurrier's brother-in-law, David Reaves, off the South Carolina staff to Tennessee. The Ole' Ball Coach certainly won't forget about that one.
Despite accusing Florida of cheating, Kiffin allegedly went after the Gators' receivers coach, Billy Gonzales, while Florida was preparing for the national championship game. However, Gonzales did not take the job. Ouch.
Kiffin then went after Forbes magazine's most powerful man in sports, Alabama head coach Nick Saban, hiring Lance Thompson, one of Alabama's best recruiters. Maybe Thompson can go over the rules with Kiffin one more time. Saban has since asked all of his committed recruits to not take visits to Tennessee.
Finally, Georgia head coach Mark Richt bested Kiffin once again. Not only did he snag Marlon Brown, Tennessee's number one recruit, he also kept one of the Bulldogs' best recruiters from going to Knoxville. Kiffin offered recruiter Rodney Garner a $400,000 bonus to join the Volunteers, but he turned it down, choosing to stay in Athens. Ouch.
Kiffin can try all he wants to bring some excitement to Rocky Top, even if it means ruffling a few feathers while rebuilding the program. However, he needs to understand what he's doing in the big picture. He has now made himself the biggest target in the SEC next year, and he doesn't really have the firepower to thwart the attack. We've seen what Urban Meyer can do when he wants to seek revenge. We've seen how motivated Mark Richt can get his team. We've seen how surgical Nick Saban can be when the Tide rolls. Next year, Tennessee goes to the Swamp and Tuscaloosa. Georgia and South Carolina will come to Knoxville. Don't expect any house warming gifts.
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
A Look Back at the BCS
Before the BCS bowls occurred, I put out a list of matchups I would much rather see than the ones that would ultimately be played. Now that the college football season is over, it's time to look back at what went right, and what went wrong, with my selections.BCS Championship: Florida beats Oklahoma
My pick: Same
-Overall, it was a competitive game, and one that didn't disappoint, aside from not being a shootout as many expected. Tim Tebow is coming back for his senior season and I fully expect him to solidify his place as the greatest college football player in history. Florida's defense really clamped down on Oklahoma, who certainly missed DeMarco Murray, and held them to only two touchdowns. Florida's offense played well, mostly thanks to Tebow, and showed how many weapons they truly have. Thank you Florida, for not letting me down in big games. I had the Gators picked to win it all, and they came through as always.
Rose Bowl: USC rolls over Penn State
My pick: USC vs. Texas
-USC really showed how much of a juggernaut they can be and how many athletes they bring to that program. USC had this game wrapped up by halftime and Penn State was purely outclassed. While this game had promise on paper, I would have preferred to see Colt McCoy and the Texas offense square off against USC's stacked defense. I think that matchup would have really shown what can win you championships in college football, high-powered offense or lockdown defense.
Sugar Bowl: Utah upsets Alabama
My pick: Texas Tech vs. Alabama
-I need to admit it, I was completely wrong on this one. I had Texas Tech penciled in, to match old school versus new school in this game. I thought Utah would get crushed and be put in their place. I thought Texas Tech's unconventional offense would be a great dichotomy to pit against Nick Saban's traditional style of hard defense and a tough ground game. Instead, Texas Tech couldn't even win their own bowl game against Ole Miss, and Alabama didn't even show up for the Sugar Bowl. While I give Utah all the credit in the world for beating all of their opponents and really taking it to Alabama, I have to say the Crimson Tide were extremely uninspired in this game. Alabama's top lineman, tackle Andre Smith was suspended for allegedly having illegal discussions with an agent, and was a microcosm of where the Crimson Tide were mentally, completely checked out of the game and looking ahead.
However, I don't want to write Utah's victory off as just a win against an unwilling opponent. The Utes did everything they were supposed to do and were completely prepared for this game. However, I don't think they deserve to be in discussion for the national championship just yet. Remember, this was a team that barely got by TCU earlier in the year when the Horned Frogs' kicker missed two makeable field goals that would have sealed the game and a Michigan team that had its worst record in school history.
Orange Bowl: Virginia Tech beats Cincinnati
My pick: Same
-I picked this game to be the sacrificial lamb of the BCS bowls and it totally proved my point. Both of these teams are incredibly boring and attract no one except for alumni and current students. In the end, it was nothing memorable and showed that neither team was worthy of a BCS invitation.
Fiesta Bowl: Texas squeaks past Ohio State
My pick: Utah vs. Boise State
-Again, I have some crow to eat on this. I originally wanted to see the two undefeated, non-BCS conference schools duke it out to see which one was more deserving of being in the upper echelon of college programs. However, Utah showed they belonged with the big boys, while Boise St. couldn't get past TCU in the San Diego County Credit Union Pointsettia Bowl (the name is so bad, you always have to say the full title when you bring it up).
Orange Bowl: Virginia Tech beats Cincinnati
My pick: Same
-I picked this game to be the sacrificial lamb of the BCS bowls and it totally proved my point. Both of these teams are incredibly boring and attract no one except for alumni and current students. In the end, it was nothing memorable and showed that neither team was worthy of a BCS invitation.
Fiesta Bowl: Texas squeaks past Ohio State
My pick: Utah vs. Boise State
-Again, I have some crow to eat on this. I originally wanted to see the two undefeated, non-BCS conference schools duke it out to see which one was more deserving of being in the upper echelon of college programs. However, Utah showed they belonged with the big boys, while Boise St. couldn't get past TCU in the San Diego County Credit Union Pointsettia Bowl (the name is so bad, you always have to say the full title when you bring it up).
While Texas versus Ohio State turned out to be a good game, Ohio State again showed they can't win the big ones. While the Buckeyes didn't completely fall on their collective face this time around, it still shows they don't deserve BCS bids just because they travel well and bring lots of money. Ohio State needs to show they can actually win something of importance (maybe a big non-conference game?) to prove they deserve an invitation to a major bowl. If the Buckeyes lose two games, and there's an undefeated team out there in the top 10, the undefeated team should go. I'm tired of see the Buckeyes lose game after game when it actually means something. Texas showed they couldn't just roll over everyone with their big-time offense. The Longhorns were losing 6-3 at halftime and only amassed 24 points. While it was a good game and Texas still came out victorious, it also showed the selections for the championship game were correct. Florida and Oklahoma both deserved to be there, and Texas didn't prove otherwise.
There were greats games, upsets and letdowns. There were great matchups, snoozers and mistakes. However, I think in the end they got it right. Florida and Oklahoma deserved to be there and the other games ultimately didn't mean anything. I think Florida is the undisputed national champion, but a playoff would be a better way to get there. I made a some good calls and some bad calls, but things ultimately went my way.
There were greats games, upsets and letdowns. There were great matchups, snoozers and mistakes. However, I think in the end they got it right. Florida and Oklahoma deserved to be there and the other games ultimately didn't mean anything. I think Florida is the undisputed national champion, but a playoff would be a better way to get there. I made a some good calls and some bad calls, but things ultimately went my way.
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Rethinking the College Football Playoff Idea
About a month and a half ago, I unveiled quite possibly the greatest college football playoff scenario anyone has ever fathomed. However, while I think my idea is fantastic and should be installed immediately, I forgot how stupid some people choose to be. While watching ESPN's "Outside the Lines," they ran a segment talking with Congressman Joe Barton of Texas, the ranking Republican on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, who is trying to pass legislation to kill the BCS and force a college playoff.
First, let me rant. Congressman Barton, looking at the tough times this country is facing as the ranking Republican member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, don't you think you should be focused on such things like, I don't know, energy or commerce? Maybe you could try working on fixing the deep recession our economy has slipped into during your time on the Hill? I disliked how Congress got involved with professional baseball, but I really can't stand how you're trying to force the hand of the NCAA into whatever you want. What power did you usurp and who anointed you as the decision maker on how to run this country's most beloved sport? Get off your high horse, Rep. Barton, this isn't your fight and you should be concentrating on fixing the problems you have been assigned to and for the people of your district that elected you.
Ok, rant over, let's get back to the topic. The stupidity that came from the "Outside the Lines" discussion baffled me. It was as if Rep. Barton entered with no forethought or research as to the implementation of his plan. This idiot went on for nearly 10 minutes about how he would change college football to get an undisputed champion.
Congressman Barton's plan called for the shortening of the collge regular season and for every bowl game to serve as a venue for an individual playoff matchup. He wanted to go back to "the good ole days" of when he was in college and there were only nine or 10 games a season. After every team's schedule would be slashed, we would then move on to a playoff system of nearly 70 teams. We would then be subjected to weeks of horrendous matchups before getting to the heart of the matter. Even NCAA basketball's March Madness takes so long, it overflows into April. A larger tournament for football could take nearly two months!
This is truly one of the worst ideas I've ever heard on the subject. The reason the NCAA says there isn't a playoff is because it would take away from the most exciting regular season in sports. Congressman Barton wants to shorten that regular season. He then wants to have a huge playoff just like March Madness. By including close to 70 teams in the playoff, you are allowing some of the worst teams in Division I-A to participate. How many people are intrigued by a Florida-Louisiana Tech first round matchup? Didn't think so. Football doesn't have the possibilities of sustained upsets like basketball does. You will never see a George Mason-like occurrence in college football. There will never be a scenario where Kent State tries to run the table after beating Texas, USC, Oklahoma and needs to get past Alabama to make the Final Four. That would never happen.
Rep. Barton's plan is not well thought out. In fact, it sounds like he made it up on the fly. He has not taken into consideration the committments that have been made by every school. By shortening the regular season, you will kill every team's non-conference schedule, as they are contractually obligated to play their in-conference opponents. Therefore, in order to bring us that fantastic Florida-Louisiana Tech matchup, the Florida-Florida St. game will have to be cancelled. Don't worry Rep. Barton, the fans will love it. Who needs rivalries anyway? Games like South Carolina-Clemson, Georgia-Georgia Tech, maybe even Notre Dame-USC will have to be cut to make room for the Grandaddy playoff finale. I'd love to hear Barton explain that to all the fans.
Finally, Barton has not figured out the name of this entire game, money. You think a political figure would know how that goes, wouldn't you? As the economy stalls, budget cuts for public institutions soon follow. As big of a cash cow as college football is, you would think schools would turn to football for help, but then Barton wants to get in the way. By shortening the regular season, you'd be cutting home games, and large sources of revenue, for every school in the country. As schools face budget cuts, I'd love to see Barton go to Ohio State and say, "Sorry, you know the ticket and concession sales of more than 110,000 people you were counting on from your season opener? That's gone now." If the regular season gets cut, Barton will have the President and Athletic Director from every school in the entire country at his doorstep with hands out, demanding billions of dollars to make up for the lost revenue he cost them by cutting the regular season.
I don't like the bowl system, but goodness, it's a million times better than what Congressman Barton has proposed. I want a college football playoff, but you can always count on some idiot to ruin a great idea. The problem with the playoff is that every person has a different idea of how it needs to happen. I want my way, and my way only. You will ruin college football with a 64+ team playoff for the national championship and I'd rather have a Papajohns.com Bowl that I will never watch than an oversized behemoth of a playoff that will kill the sport I love.
First, let me rant. Congressman Barton, looking at the tough times this country is facing as the ranking Republican member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, don't you think you should be focused on such things like, I don't know, energy or commerce? Maybe you could try working on fixing the deep recession our economy has slipped into during your time on the Hill? I disliked how Congress got involved with professional baseball, but I really can't stand how you're trying to force the hand of the NCAA into whatever you want. What power did you usurp and who anointed you as the decision maker on how to run this country's most beloved sport? Get off your high horse, Rep. Barton, this isn't your fight and you should be concentrating on fixing the problems you have been assigned to and for the people of your district that elected you.
Ok, rant over, let's get back to the topic. The stupidity that came from the "Outside the Lines" discussion baffled me. It was as if Rep. Barton entered with no forethought or research as to the implementation of his plan. This idiot went on for nearly 10 minutes about how he would change college football to get an undisputed champion.
Congressman Barton's plan called for the shortening of the collge regular season and for every bowl game to serve as a venue for an individual playoff matchup. He wanted to go back to "the good ole days" of when he was in college and there were only nine or 10 games a season. After every team's schedule would be slashed, we would then move on to a playoff system of nearly 70 teams. We would then be subjected to weeks of horrendous matchups before getting to the heart of the matter. Even NCAA basketball's March Madness takes so long, it overflows into April. A larger tournament for football could take nearly two months!
This is truly one of the worst ideas I've ever heard on the subject. The reason the NCAA says there isn't a playoff is because it would take away from the most exciting regular season in sports. Congressman Barton wants to shorten that regular season. He then wants to have a huge playoff just like March Madness. By including close to 70 teams in the playoff, you are allowing some of the worst teams in Division I-A to participate. How many people are intrigued by a Florida-Louisiana Tech first round matchup? Didn't think so. Football doesn't have the possibilities of sustained upsets like basketball does. You will never see a George Mason-like occurrence in college football. There will never be a scenario where Kent State tries to run the table after beating Texas, USC, Oklahoma and needs to get past Alabama to make the Final Four. That would never happen.
Rep. Barton's plan is not well thought out. In fact, it sounds like he made it up on the fly. He has not taken into consideration the committments that have been made by every school. By shortening the regular season, you will kill every team's non-conference schedule, as they are contractually obligated to play their in-conference opponents. Therefore, in order to bring us that fantastic Florida-Louisiana Tech matchup, the Florida-Florida St. game will have to be cancelled. Don't worry Rep. Barton, the fans will love it. Who needs rivalries anyway? Games like South Carolina-Clemson, Georgia-Georgia Tech, maybe even Notre Dame-USC will have to be cut to make room for the Grandaddy playoff finale. I'd love to hear Barton explain that to all the fans.
Finally, Barton has not figured out the name of this entire game, money. You think a political figure would know how that goes, wouldn't you? As the economy stalls, budget cuts for public institutions soon follow. As big of a cash cow as college football is, you would think schools would turn to football for help, but then Barton wants to get in the way. By shortening the regular season, you'd be cutting home games, and large sources of revenue, for every school in the country. As schools face budget cuts, I'd love to see Barton go to Ohio State and say, "Sorry, you know the ticket and concession sales of more than 110,000 people you were counting on from your season opener? That's gone now." If the regular season gets cut, Barton will have the President and Athletic Director from every school in the entire country at his doorstep with hands out, demanding billions of dollars to make up for the lost revenue he cost them by cutting the regular season.
I don't like the bowl system, but goodness, it's a million times better than what Congressman Barton has proposed. I want a college football playoff, but you can always count on some idiot to ruin a great idea. The problem with the playoff is that every person has a different idea of how it needs to happen. I want my way, and my way only. You will ruin college football with a 64+ team playoff for the national championship and I'd rather have a Papajohns.com Bowl that I will never watch than an oversized behemoth of a playoff that will kill the sport I love.
Monday, January 5, 2009
Redskins Quick Hits
Frustration
The fall of the Washington Redskins in the second half of the season appalled me. Jim Zorn's offense was so terrible I could barely stand to watch. How simple could your formula be? Run for two yards, run for no gain, throw an incompletion, then punt. I know the team was banged up at the end of the season, but no one stepped up. There's no leadership on that offense and it showed. Santana Moss is a quality receiver, but lets his actions speak for him. He won't be the guy in the huddle getting everyone hyped up. Chris Cooley can always be counted on in possession, but isn't a big play threat and it seems he would rather open his mouth on his blog than on the field. Clinton Portis is the face of the franchise, but his outspoken personality doesn't rally anyone around him, it usually ostracizes his teammates. Antwaan Randle El talks, but doesn't back it up with production. His "dangerous returner" label needs to be taken off and he jumps around and dances more than he catches the ball. He's more frustrating than appealing. Jason Campbell bothers me, he doesn't look like he'll ever be a leader, but we'll get to that in a minute.
Ineptitude
The rookies on this team did nothing. Even Chris Horton, the steal of the draft, didn't do much in terms of big plays after week 2. The three second-round receivers were so disappointing, but I don't know who to blame. Did Jim Zorn not give them a chance by putting them in games, or are they just that bad that they can't get themselves on the field? Either way, we got nothing from the rookies, not even a glimmer of hope for the future. There is not a single one of them that I can say, "Wait till next year, this guy will blow up." Nothing about them says, "You can hold off on this position in free agency and the draft, we're set." Every position on the team needs to be evaluated. I love Colt Brennan and would like to see what he can do in a real game. Unfortunately, he wasn't given that opportunity this season. I hope he gets a shot at some point.
The rookies on this team did nothing. Even Chris Horton, the steal of the draft, didn't do much in terms of big plays after week 2. The three second-round receivers were so disappointing, but I don't know who to blame. Did Jim Zorn not give them a chance by putting them in games, or are they just that bad that they can't get themselves on the field? Either way, we got nothing from the rookies, not even a glimmer of hope for the future. There is not a single one of them that I can say, "Wait till next year, this guy will blow up." Nothing about them says, "You can hold off on this position in free agency and the draft, we're set." Every position on the team needs to be evaluated. I love Colt Brennan and would like to see what he can do in a real game. Unfortunately, he wasn't given that opportunity this season. I hope he gets a shot at some point.
Monotony
Jason Campbell's demeanor bothers me to no end. At the beginning of the season, sports reporters and coaches raved about how you could never tell whether he'd thrown a touchdown or an interception and how he fit perfectly with Jim Zorn's "stay medium" mentality. I see it an entirely different way. Sure he won't get too down, but he never gets up either. He never plays with any fire and almost looks like he doesn't even have a passion for the game. If you "stay medium," you settle for mediocrity. I don't see the advantage of it, I understand keeping an even keel, but football is a game of emotion just as much as it's physicality and schematics. That's why the "any given Sunday" mantra is always alive, because you never know how a team will come out and play. The underdog might be more fired up and want the game more, and that's why they win. Jason Campbell will never lead this team anywhere if he doesn't step up to the plate and show some swagger out there. He just seems content to stay straight faced, unfazed by anything, but not excited by anything, indifferent to the game as a whole and ok with whatever happens.
Jason Campbell's demeanor bothers me to no end. At the beginning of the season, sports reporters and coaches raved about how you could never tell whether he'd thrown a touchdown or an interception and how he fit perfectly with Jim Zorn's "stay medium" mentality. I see it an entirely different way. Sure he won't get too down, but he never gets up either. He never plays with any fire and almost looks like he doesn't even have a passion for the game. If you "stay medium," you settle for mediocrity. I don't see the advantage of it, I understand keeping an even keel, but football is a game of emotion just as much as it's physicality and schematics. That's why the "any given Sunday" mantra is always alive, because you never know how a team will come out and play. The underdog might be more fired up and want the game more, and that's why they win. Jason Campbell will never lead this team anywhere if he doesn't step up to the plate and show some swagger out there. He just seems content to stay straight faced, unfazed by anything, but not excited by anything, indifferent to the game as a whole and ok with whatever happens.
Disrespect
London Fletcher finally snapped about the Pro Bowl, and I believe justly so. He was again overlooked by his peers (not the fans) as Patrick Willis and Jon Beason will represent the NFC at middle linebacker. While those two did have more tackles than Fletcher this season, Fletcher has more tackles than any other player this decade. For him to be passed over again is another slap in the face of what could be a Hall of Fame career if people paid closer attention. Don't worry London, no one is faulting you for getting upset about the decision, at least someone on this team is playing with some fire out there.
London Fletcher finally snapped about the Pro Bowl, and I believe justly so. He was again overlooked by his peers (not the fans) as Patrick Willis and Jon Beason will represent the NFC at middle linebacker. While those two did have more tackles than Fletcher this season, Fletcher has more tackles than any other player this decade. For him to be passed over again is another slap in the face of what could be a Hall of Fame career if people paid closer attention. Don't worry London, no one is faulting you for getting upset about the decision, at least someone on this team is playing with some fire out there.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
